arXiv:2409.04649cs.SIcs.IR2024-09

发现用户个人口味比群体智慧更影响商品评分预测。

Preserving Individuality while Following the Crowd: Understanding the Role of User Taste and Crowd Wisdom in Online Product Rating Prediction

  • 用动态树结构同时捕捉用户和商品的历史评分趋势。
  • 实测显示个人偏好远强于群体平均,跨模型均成立。
  • 适合需要高可扩展性的工业级评分系统开发者。

众多算法被用于在线商品评分预测,但用户与产品信息对最终评分的影响机制仍不明确。现有研究多依赖受限数据设定,忽视了冷启动、跨类别信息利用及可扩展性等实际挑战。为此,我们提出一种新颖且实用的方法,通过持续更新的动态树表示,强调用户与商品层面的历史评分,有效捕捉其时序动态,实现跨类别用户信息利用,并自然解决冷启动问题。同时,我们设计了高效的处理策略,使该方法具备高可扩展性和易部署性。在真实工业场景的全面实验表明,该方法表现优异。尤为关键的是,我们的发现揭示:在商品评分预测中,个体口味显著优于群体智慧,这一结论与其它领域常见的“群体智慧”现象相悖。该主导效应在多种模型(如提升树、循环神经网络、Transformer)中保持一致,涵盖整体人群、单个品类及冷启动场景。研究凸显了个体口味的重要性,也验证了方法在不同架构下的鲁棒性。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Numerous algorithms have been developed for online product rating prediction, but the specific influence of user and product information in determining the final prediction score remains largely unexplored. Existing research often relies on narrowly defined data settings, which overlooks real-world challenges such as the cold-start problem, cross-category information utilization, and scalability and deployment issues. To delve deeper into these aspects, and particularly to uncover the roles of individual user taste and collective wisdom, we propose a unique and practical approach that emphasizes historical ratings at both the user and product levels, encapsulated using a continuously updated dynamic tree representation. This representation effectively captures the temporal dynamics of users and products, leverages user information across product categories, and provides a natural solution to the cold-start problem. Furthermore, we have developed an efficient data processing strategy that makes this approach highly scalable and easily deployable. Comprehensive experiments in real industry settings demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach. Notably, our findings reveal that individual taste dominates over collective wisdom in online product rating prediction, a perspective that contrasts with the commonly observed wisdom of the crowd phenomenon in other domains. This dominance of individual user taste is consistent across various model types, including the boosting tree model, recurrent neural network (RNN), and transformer-based architectures. This observation holds true across the overall population, within individual product categories, and in cold-start scenarios. Our findings underscore the significance of individual user tastes in the context of online product rating prediction and the robustness of our approach across different model architectures.

评分预测用户建模冷启动动态树

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。