arXiv:2409.18394cs.RO2024-09被引 3

对比三种机器人控制方式,发现非专家用户操作效率差距明显。

Towards Accessible Robot Control: Comparing Kinesthetic Teaching, SpaceMouse Teleoperation, and a Mixed Reality Interface

  • 用空间鼠标、混合现实界面和力控教学比对操控表现
  • 两种远程操控方式表现相近,复杂任务成功率下降
  • 强调为普通用户设计易用接口的必要性

遥操作系统是实现人类对机器人控制的关键工具。尽管已开发出多种接口,但用户通过这些接口的表现仍远低于直接人力引导控制的能力,尤其在用户缺乏经验或不熟悉平台时更为明显。本文通过一项涵盖两个机器人平台和六个复杂操作任务的综合用户研究,比较了空间鼠标遥操作、混合现实(MR)界面与力控教学(非遥操作基准)的表现。定量结果显示,空间鼠标与MR界面表现相当,仅在两项任务中存在显著差异;随着任务复杂度提升,成功率下降。定性分析也反映了这一趋势,指出物理负荷差异,并识别出影响用户执行、学习与理解的关键接口属性。研究量化了当前遥操作系统在非专家用户中的局限性,并整合了25名参与者主观反馈。结果强调,在个人或日常环境中部署自主机器人时,必须为非专家用户设计并严格评估遥操作系统,以保障可用性、效率与可及性。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Teleoperation interfaces are essential tools for enabling human control of robotic systems. Although a wide range of interfaces has been developed, a persistent gap remains between the level of performance humans can achieve through these interfaces and the capabilities afforded by direct human-guided robot control. This gap is further exacerbated when users are inexperienced or unfamiliar with the robotic platform or control interface. In this work, we aim to better characterize this performance gap for non-expert users by comparing two teleoperation approaches, SpaceMouse teleoperation and a Mixed Reality (MR) interface, against kinesthetic teaching as a non-teleoperation baseline. All three approaches were evaluated in a comprehensive user study involving two robotic platforms and six complex manipulation tasks. Quantitative results show that the SpaceMouse and MR interfaces performed comparably, with significant differences in task completion observed for only two tasks, and success rates declining as task complexity increased. Qualitative analysis reflected these trends, highlighting differences in Physical Demand and identifying interface attributes that influence users' ability to perform, learn, and understand. This study quantifies the limitations of current teleoperation methods and incorporates subjective feedback from 25 participants. The results highlight the critical need to design and rigorously evaluate teleoperation systems for non-expert users, particularly in contexts where autonomous robots are deployed in personal or everyday environments, to ensure usability, efficiency, and accessibility.

机器人控制人机交互用户体验遥操作

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。