通过实验解析琴拾音器绕线数与线径对音色的影响。
Guitar Pickups I: Analysis of the Effect of Winding and Wire Gauge on Single Coil Electric Guitar Pickups
- 控制变量法分别测试绕线数和线径对单线圈拾音器的影响。
- 绕线越多,共振频率越低,峰值幅度越大;线径越粗,输出越亮越强。
- 结果解释了市面上拾音器音色差异的物理根源,适合乐器设计者参考。
吉他拾音器已生产近百年,其音色差异的原因仍存在广泛争议。本文是系列研究的第一篇,旨在为拾音器制作引入科学方法。此前研究多分析市售产品,但它们在多个参数上存在差异。本研究首次采用仅改变单一参数的实验拾音器,聚焦单线圈拾音器的核心特性:绕线数与线径。制作了一系列斯特拉托风格单线圈拾音器,绕线数覆盖5000至12000匝,使用42和44 AWG两种常见线径。通过频响分析仪测量阻抗,发现共振频率随绕线数呈指数下降,共振峰幅度则随绕线数线性上升;线径越粗,相同匝数下共振频率更高、峰值幅度更大。这些参数影响音色:共振频率决定音色明暗,幅度决定输出增益。增加绕线数使音色变暗且输出更高;线径更粗则输出更强、音色更亮——与市售拾音器表现一致。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Guitar Pickups have been in production for nearly 100 years, and the question of how exactly one pickup is tonally superior to another is still subject to a high level of debate. This paper is the first in a set demystifying the production of guitar pickups and introducing a level of scientific procedure to the conversation. Previous studies have analysed commercial off-the-shelf pickups, but these differ from each other in multiple ways. The novelty of this study is that dedicated experimental pickups were created, which vary only one parameter at a time in order to allow scientific study. The most fundamental qualities of a single-coil pickup are investigated: in this paper, number of turns and gauge of wire. A set of single-coil stratocaster-style pickups were created, with the number of turns of wire varied across the commercially available range (5000-12000 turns), and this was done for two widely used wire gauges (42 and 44 AWG). A frequency response analyser was used to obtain impedance across a frequency range. It is shown that resonant frequency decreases exponentially with number of turns, while the magnitude of the resonant peak increases linearly with number of turns. The wire gauge used has a significant impact on both parameters, with the thicker wire giving higher resonant frequencies and higher magnitudes than the thinner wire for the same number of turns. These impact the sound associated with the pickup: the resonant frequency is linked to the perceived tone of the pickup, and the magnitude to the output amplitude and hence 'gain.' Increasing the number of turns will give a higher output pickup with a darker tone, and thicker wire gives louder outputs and brighter tones - consistent with what can be observed in commercial pickups.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。