评测o1模型在复杂任务中的规划能力,发现其约束遵守强但空间推理弱。
On The Planning Abilities of OpenAI's o1 Models: Feasibility, Optimality, and Generalizability
- 通过自评估和约束追踪提升决策可靠性
- 在结构化环境中优于GPT-4,但存在冗余动作与次优解
- 适合研究大模型规划局限与空间推理改进的学者
近期大语言模型在复杂推理任务中表现突出,但其规划能力仍待深入探索。本文评估OpenAI o1模型在多种基准任务中的规划性能,聚焦可行性、最优性与泛化性。在高约束任务(如$ extit{Barman}$、$ extit{Tyreworld}$)和空间复杂环境(如$ extit{Termes}$、$ extit{Floortile}$)中,o1-preview展现出较强的自我评估与约束遵循能力,但在决策与记忆管理方面存在瓶颈,尤其在需强空间推理的任务中表现不足。结果表明,o1-preview在遵循任务约束与状态转移管理上优于GPT-4,但常产生冗余动作,且在空间复杂任务中泛化能力弱。本研究为理解大模型规划局限提供基础洞见,并指明未来在记忆管理、决策优化与泛化能力方面的改进方向。代码见https://github.com/VITA-Group/o1-planning。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have showcased their ability to perform complex reasoning tasks, but their effectiveness in planning remains underexplored. In this study, we evaluate the planning capabilities of OpenAI's o1 models across a variety of benchmark tasks, focusing on three key aspects: feasibility, optimality, and generalizability. Through empirical evaluations on constraint-heavy tasks (e.g., $\textit{Barman}$, $\textit{Tyreworld}$) and spatially complex environments (e.g., $\textit{Termes}$, $\textit{Floortile}$), we highlight o1-preview's strengths in self-evaluation and constraint-following, while also identifying bottlenecks in decision-making and memory management, particularly in tasks requiring robust spatial reasoning. Our results reveal that o1-preview outperforms GPT-4 in adhering to task constraints and managing state transitions in structured environments. However, the model often generates suboptimal solutions with redundant actions and struggles to generalize effectively in spatially complex tasks. This pilot study provides foundational insights into the planning limitations of LLMs, offering key directions for future research on improving memory management, decision-making, and generalization in LLM-based planning. Code available at https://github.com/VITA-Group/o1-planning.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。