用敏感属性提升医疗AI性能,只要不损害子群体表现就可接受差异。
Positive-Sum Fairness: Leveraging Demographic Attributes to Achieve Fair AI Outcomes Without Sacrificing Group Gains

- 引入正和公平:允许因使用种族等属性提升整体性能
- 实验显示利用种族信息可提高整体准确率但扩大组间差距
- 适合关注医疗AI公平性与性能平衡的研究者
医疗AI中的公平性日益成为医疗交付的关键。现有研究多强调性能均等,但我们认为性能变化带来的公平性下降可能是有害或无害的,取决于变化类型及敏感属性的使用方式。为此,我们提出正和公平概念:只要不损害各子群体的个体表现,性能提升导致的组间差距扩大也是可接受的。这使得与疾病相关的敏感属性(如种族)可用于提升模型性能而不牺牲公平性。通过对比四种使用不同种族编码策略的CNN模型,结果表明:完全去除图像中的种族编码有助于缩小子群体间的性能差距;而将种族作为输入则能提升整体性能,尽管加剧了组间差异。这些更大差距在正和公平框架下被重新评估,以区分有害与非有害的不公平现象。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Fairness in medical AI is increasingly recognized as a crucial aspect of healthcare delivery. While most of the prior work done on fairness emphasizes the importance of equal performance, we argue that decreases in fairness can be either harmful or non-harmful, depending on the type of change and how sensitive attributes are used. To this end, we introduce the notion of positive-sum fairness, which states that an increase in performance that results in a larger group disparity is acceptable as long as it does not come at the cost of individual subgroup performance. This allows sensitive attributes correlated with the disease to be used to increase performance without compromising on fairness. We illustrate this idea by comparing four CNN models that make different use of the race attribute in the training phase. The results show that removing all demographic encodings from the images helps close the gap in performance between the different subgroups, whereas leveraging the race attribute as a model's input increases the overall performance while widening the disparities between subgroups. These larger gaps are then put in perspective of the collective benefit through our notion of positive-sum fairness to distinguish harmful from non harmful disparities.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。