提出一套可复用的RAG系统评估方法,解决其效果难验证的问题。
A Methodology for Evaluating RAG Systems: A Case Study On Configuration Dependency Validation
- 构建可复用的RAG评估框架,强调基线与指标选择
- 在软件配置依赖验证中实现领域最高准确率
- 适合研究RAG设计与评估的开发者和研究人员
检索增强生成(RAG)是融合多种组件、设计决策和领域适配的技术,旨在提升大语言模型能力并缓解幻觉、知识过时或缺失等问题。然而,由于缺乏统一的评估方法,当前RAG系统开发高度依赖实验,难以获得可靠结果。本文提出首个可复用的RAG评估方法论蓝图,并以真实软件工程任务——跨技术软件配置依赖验证为例进行演示。主要贡献包括:(i) 提出一套可复用的评估方法设计,包含可操作指南;(ii) 基于此方法构建的RAG系统在依赖验证任务中达到领域最高准确率。演示关键洞察包括:恰当基线与指标的选择至关重要,需基于定性失败分析进行系统性优化,且应清晰记录关键设计决策以支持复现与评估。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) is an umbrella of different components, design decisions, and domain-specific adaptations to enhance the capabilities of large language models and counter their limitations regarding hallucination and outdated and missing knowledge. Since it is unclear which design decisions lead to a satisfactory performance, developing RAG systems is often experimental and needs to follow a systematic and sound methodology to gain sound and reliable results. However, there is currently no generally accepted methodology for RAG evaluation despite a growing interest in this technology. In this paper, we propose a first blueprint of a methodology for a sound and reliable evaluation of RAG systems and demonstrate its applicability on a real-world software engineering research task: the validation of configuration dependencies across software technologies. In summary, we make two novel contributions: (i) A novel, reusable methodological design for evaluating RAG systems, including a demonstration that represents a guideline, and (ii) a RAG system, which has been developed following this methodology, that achieves the highest accuracy in the field of dependency validation. For the blueprint's demonstration, the key insights are the crucial role of choosing appropriate baselines and metrics, the necessity for systematic RAG refinements derived from qualitative failure analysis, as well as the reporting practices of key design decision to foster replication and evaluation.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。