arXiv:2410.20062eess.IVcs.AI2024-10被引 4

对比多种模型诊断膝骨关节炎严重程度,视觉变换器表现最佳。

Transforming Precision: A Comparative Analysis of Vision Transformers, CNNs, and Traditional ML for Knee Osteoarthritis Severity Diagnosis

  • 用自注意力机制的视觉变换器捕捉影像深层特征
  • 最大准确率达66.14%,AUC超0.835,优于传统方法
  • 为临床诊断提供高精度、可信赖的智能工具

膝骨关节炎(KO)是一种退行性关节疾病,常导致剧烈疼痛与功能障碍。随着发病率上升,通过医学影像分析实现精准诊断对疾病管理至关重要。本研究比较了传统机器学习与新兴深度学习模型在膝关节X光片上诊断KO严重程度的表现。研究未提出新架构,而是验证了现有视觉变换器(ViT)模型在医学影像中的强大适用性与相对优势。数据来自骨关节炎行动倡议(OAI)数据库,包含5个严重程度等级且类别分布不均。传统模型如GaussianNB和KNN在特征提取上表现不佳;卷积神经网络(如Inception-V3、VGG-19)通过学习层次化视觉模式,准确率提升至55%-65%。而视觉变换器(如Da-VIT、GCViT、MaxViT)凭借自注意力机制,在测试中达到66.14%准确率、0.703精确率、0.614召回率,AUC超过0.835,成为最优选择。研究结果支持将先进ViT模型整合进临床诊断流程,有望显著提升KO评估的精准性与可靠性。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Knee osteoarthritis(KO) is a degenerative joint disease that can cause severe pain and impairment. With increased prevalence, precise diagnosis by medical imaging analytics is crucial for appropriate illness management. This research investigates a comparative analysis between traditional machine learning techniques and new deep learning models for diagnosing KO severity from X-ray pictures. This study does not introduce new architectural innovations but rather illuminates the robust applicability and comparative effectiveness of pre-existing ViT models in a medical imaging context, specifically for KO severity diagnosis. The insights garnered from this comparative analysis advocate for the integration of advanced ViT models in clinical diagnostic workflows, potentially revolutionizing the precision and reliability of KO assessments. This study does not introduce new architectural innovations but rather illuminates the robust applicability and comparative effectiveness of pre-existing ViT models in a medical imaging context, specifically for KO severity diagnosis. The insights garnered from this comparative analysis advocate for the integration of advanced ViT models in clinical diagnostic workflows, potentially revolutionizing the precision & reliability of KO assessments. The study utilizes an osteoarthritis dataset from the Osteoarthritis Initiative (OAI) comprising images with 5 severity categories and uneven class distribution. While classic machine learning models like GaussianNB and KNN struggle in feature extraction, Convolutional Neural Networks such as Inception-V3, VGG-19 achieve better accuracy between 55-65% by learning hierarchical visual patterns. However, Vision Transformer architectures like Da-VIT, GCViT and MaxViT emerge as indisputable champions, displaying 66.14% accuracy, 0.703 precision, 0.614 recall, AUC exceeding 0.835 thanks to self-attention processes.

膝骨关节炎视觉变换器医学影像分类诊断

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。