arXiv:2410.21898cs.CYcs.CL2024-10被引 2

分析《纽约时报》和福克斯新闻中种族与性别形象的长期偏见

A Longitudinal Analysis of Racial and Gender Bias in New York Times and Fox News Images and Articles

  • 用机器学习识别图像中人物种族与年龄,构建双媒体对比数据集
  • 少数族裔在图片中出现频率低且位置不突出,尤其福克斯更严重
  • 《纽约时报》对少数族裔呈现更多,但内容仍局限于受害者或施害者角色

新闻中不同种族与性别群体的呈现方式深刻影响公众认知。为填补纵向研究空白,本文构建两个机器学习分类器以检测图像中人物的种族与年龄。整合来自《纽约时报》(NYT)和福克斯新闻(Fox)的123,337张图片与441,321篇在线文章,采用两种计算方法分析代表性。首先,图像中少数族裔出现频率低且显著性弱,尽管NYT比Fox更常展示少数族裔。其次,文本分析显示部分少数族裔报道范围狭窄,被频繁标记为冲突中的受害者或施害者。本研究提供两个开源的种族与年龄检测分类器,并揭示了美国政治光谱两端媒体在种族与性别偏见上的差异。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

The manner in which different racial and gender groups are portrayed in news coverage plays a large role in shaping public opinion. As such, understanding how such groups are portrayed in news media is of notable societal value, and has thus been a significant endeavour in both the computer and social sciences. Yet, the literature still lacks a longitudinal study examining both the frequency of appearance of different racial and gender groups in online news articles, as well as the context in which such groups are discussed. To fill this gap, we propose two machine learning classifiers to detect the race and age of a given subject. Next, we compile a dataset of 123,337 images and 441,321 online news articles from New York Times (NYT) and Fox News (Fox), and examine representation through two computational approaches. Firstly, we examine the frequency and prominence of appearance of racial and gender groups in images embedded in news articles, revealing that racial and gender minorities are largely under-represented, and when they do appear, they are featured less prominently compared to majority groups. Furthermore, we find that NYT largely features more images of racial minority groups compared to Fox. Secondly, we examine both the frequency and context with which racial minority groups are presented in article text. This reveals the narrow scope in which certain racial groups are covered and the frequency with which different groups are presented as victims and/or perpetrators in a given conflict. Taken together, our analysis contributes to the literature by providing two novel open-source classifiers to detect race and age from images, and shedding light on the racial and gender biases in news articles from venues on opposite ends of the American political spectrum.

媒体偏见图像识别社会影响数据挖掘

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。