全面对比YOLO系列12个版本,揭示各代优劣与适用场景。
YOLO Evolution: A Comprehensive Benchmark and Architectural Review of YOLOv12, YOLO11, and Their Previous Versions
- 系统评测YOLOv3至YOLOv12在多类挑战下的表现。
- YOLO11在精度与效率间平衡最优,YOLOv12性能不佳。
- 适合选型参考,指导工业与学术界模型部署决策。
本研究对各类YOLO(You Only Look Once)算法进行了全面基准分析,是首次对YOLOv3至最新版YOLOv12在多种目标检测挑战上的综合实验评估。评估涵盖不同物体尺寸、多样宽高比及单类小物体检测等挑战,覆盖具有不同难度的数据集。为确保评估可靠性,采用包含精确率(Precision)、召回率(Recall)、平均精度(mAP)、处理时间、GFLOPs和模型大小在内的全面指标体系。分析显示:YOLOv9虽精度高但小物体检测与效率不足;YOLOv10因架构设计导致重叠物体检测精度较低,但在速度与效率上表现优异;YOLO11家族持续展现卓越性能,兼顾精度与效率;而YOLOv12复杂架构引入计算开销却未带来显著性能提升。研究结果为产业界与学术界选择合适模型提供关键参考,并指引未来优化方向。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
This study presents a comprehensive benchmark analysis of various YOLO (You Only Look Once) algorithms. It represents the first comprehensive experimental evaluation of YOLOv3 to the latest version, YOLOv12, on various object detection challenges. The challenges considered include varying object sizes, diverse aspect ratios, and small-sized objects of a single class, ensuring a comprehensive assessment across datasets with distinct challenges. To ensure a robust evaluation, we employ a comprehensive set of metrics, including Precision, Recall, Mean Average Precision (mAP), Processing Time, GFLOPs count, and Model Size. Our analysis highlights the distinctive strengths and limitations of each YOLO version. For example: YOLOv9 demonstrates substantial accuracy but struggles with detecting small objects and efficiency whereas YOLOv10 exhibits relatively lower accuracy due to architectural choices that affect its performance in overlapping object detection but excels in speed and efficiency. Additionally, the YOLO11 family consistently shows superior performance maintaining a remarkable balance of accuracy and efficiency. However, YOLOv12 delivered underwhelming results, with its complex architecture introducing computational overhead without significant performance gains. These results provide critical insights for both industry and academia, facilitating the selection of the most suitable YOLO algorithm for diverse applications and guiding future enhancements.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。