用AI生成图像促进公众参与城市空间设计,让讨论更深入
From Fake Perfects to Conversational Imperfects: Exploring Image-Generative AI as a Boundary Object for Participatory Design of Public Spaces
- 用图像生成AI引导公众讨论,重点从精确表达转向深度对话
- 参与者讨论更关注空间实际使用,而非完美效果图
- 成功依赖主持人协调人、AI与公众的互动能力
公共空间设计需在有限物理与制度条件下平衡多元利益相关者诉求。设计师常采用参与式方法,但难以将多样观点融入设计成果。图像生成人工智能(IGAI)的发展或可支持参与式设计。以往研究多聚焦于提升个体创作者的体验与表现力,而本文探讨了在复杂协作任务中,如洛杉矶某公园改造项目,如何利用IGAI推动参与式过程。通过开展工作坊与基于IGAI的访谈,发现:(1) 采纳IGAI的参与式设计,理想结果应从追求图像准确性转向激发更丰富的对话;(2) IGAI促使参与者展开更具空间意识的讨论;(3) 参与式对话的效果取决于主持人的协调能力,即其管理自身、AI与公众之间互动的能力。本文提出使用IGAI进行参与式设计的实际启示,包括成功度量标准、所需技能及设计者与公众间的权力不对称问题,并展望一系列开放研究问题。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Designing public spaces requires balancing the interests of diverse stakeholders within a constrained physical and institutional space. Designers usually approach these problems through participatory methods but struggle to incorporate diverse perspectives into design outputs. The growing capabilities of image-generative artificial intelligence (IGAI) could support participatory design. Prior work in leveraging IGAI's capabilities in design has focused on augmenting the experience and performance of individual creators. We study how IGAI could facilitate participatory processes when designing public spaces, a complex collaborative task. We conducted workshops and IGAI-mediated interviews in a real-world participatory process to upgrade a park in Los Angeles. We found (1) a shift from focusing on accuracy to fostering richer conversations as the desirable outcome of adopting IGAI in participatory design, (2) that IGAI promoted more space-aware conversations, and (3) that IGAI-mediated conversations are subject to the abilities of the facilitators in managing the interaction between themselves, the AI, and stakeholders. We contribute by discussing practical implications for using IGAI in participatory design, including success metrics, relevant skills, and asymmetries between designers and stakeholders. We finish by proposing a series of open research questions.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。