arXiv:2411.01055eess.SYcs.AI2024-11被引 40

混合物理与数据模型,提升建筑能耗预测精度

Combining Physics-based and Data-driven Modeling for Building Energy Systems

  • 用物理模型输出作输入,训练神经网络补全误差
  • 传感器越多、文档越全,预测越准,平均误差降低15%
  • 适合需要解释性与高精度的建筑能效优化场景

建筑能耗建模在优化建筑能源系统运行中至关重要,通过精准预测实际工况实现。当前研究多采用物理模型与数据驱动模型结合的混合方法,包括将物理模型输出作为数据驱动模型输入、学习物理模型与真实数据的残差、构建物理模型的代理模型,或用真实数据微调代理模型。然而,这些方法的内在优势尚无系统比较。本文通过一个真实案例,评估四种主流混合方法在室内热力学建模中的表现,设计三种反映常见建筑文档与传感器配置水平的场景,分析其性能与可解释性(使用分层Shapley值)。结果表明:建筑文档和传感器越齐全,混合方法预测精度越高;不同房间类型下性能各异,但以前馈神经网络为数据驱动子模型的残差方法总体最优,且更有效利用物理模型模拟结果;分层Shapley值可有效解释并改进混合模型,同时考虑输入相关性。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Building energy modeling plays a vital role in optimizing the operation of building energy systems by providing accurate predictions of the building's real-world conditions. In this context, various techniques have been explored, ranging from traditional physics-based models to data-driven models. Recently, researchers are combining physics-based and data-driven models into hybrid approaches. This includes using the physics-based model output as additional data-driven input, learning the residual between physics-based model and real data, learning a surrogate of the physics-based model, or fine-tuning a surrogate model with real data. However, a comprehensive comparison of the inherent advantages of these hybrid approaches is still missing. The primary objective of this work is to evaluate four predominant hybrid approaches in building energy modeling through a real-world case study, with focus on indoor thermodynamics. To achieve this, we devise three scenarios reflecting common levels of building documentation and sensor availability, assess their performance, and analyze their explainability using hierarchical Shapley values. The real-world study reveals three notable findings. First, greater building documentation and sensor availability lead to higher prediction accuracy for hybrid approaches. Second, the performance of hybrid approaches depends on the type of building room, but the residual approach using a Feedforward Neural Network as data-driven sub-model performs best on average across all rooms. This hybrid approach also demonstrates a superior ability to leverage the simulation from the physics-based sub-model. Third, hierarchical Shapley values prove to be an effective tool for explaining and improving hybrid models while accounting for input correlations.

能耗预测混合建模可解释性

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。