MRI图像质量影响脑结构分析,低质量数据会掩盖性别差异
The impact of MRI image quality on statistical and predictive analysis on voxel based morphology
- 用三个大型数据集测试图像质量对统计和分类的影响
- 小样本中低质量数据几乎无法检测出性别差异
- 传统统计需高质量图像,机器学习更依赖大样本
MRI脑扫描图像质量受头动影响,导致图像伪影,进而改变脑体积和皮层厚度等测量值。自动化图像质量评估对控制劣质图像的干扰至关重要。本研究系统检验了图像质量对单变量统计和机器学习分类的影响。基于三个公开数据集,构建了两组年龄与性别平衡的样本(n=760 和 n=1094),分析性别/性别在局部脑体积上的群体效应,并使用逻辑回归预测性别,同时校正脑容量。对3747个灰质特征进行邦弗伦尼校正的t检验显示,在小样本中,低质量数据显著削弱了发现显著性别差异的能力。样本量增加和图像质量提升均大幅提高单变量组间比较的显著性检测能力。而在性别分类任务中,尽管样本量和图像质量提升均有边际改善,但对受试者工作特征曲线下面积(AUC)影响较小。结果表明,单变量分析需更严格的图像质量控制,而机器学习应用则更依赖大样本。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Image Quality of MRI brain scans is strongly influenced by within scanner head movements and the resulting image artifacts alter derived measures like brain volume and cortical thickness. Automated image quality assessment is key to controlling for confounding effects of poor image quality. In this study, we systematically test for the influence of image quality on univariate statistics and machine learning classification. We analyzed group effects of sex/gender on local brain volume and made predictions of sex/gender using logistic regression, while correcting for brain size. From three large publicly available datasets, two age and sex-balanced samples were derived to test the generalizability of the effect for pooled sample sizes of n=760 and n=1094. Results of the Bonferroni corrected t-tests over 3747 gray matter features showed a strong influence of low-quality data on the ability to find significant sex/gender differences for the smaller sample. Increasing sample size and more so image quality showed a stark increase in detecting significant effects in univariate group comparisons. For the classification of sex/gender using logistic regression, both increasing sample size and image quality had a marginal effect on the Area under the Receiver Operating Characteristic Curve for most datasets and subsamples. Our results suggest a more stringent quality control for univariate approaches than for multivariate classification with a leaning towards higher quality for classical group statistics and bigger sample sizes for machine learning applications in neuroimaging.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。