让专业模型协作需先对齐能力,否则融合效果差。
Collective Model Intelligence Requires Compatible Specialization
- 用路由策略动态组合多层特征,提升模型融合灵活性。
- 模型越专精,内部特征越不兼容,融合后性能下降。
- 适合研究模型协同、大模型集成的开发者参考。
本文探讨了通过平均中间特征(即模型合并)整合模型的局限性,提出通过‘兼容专业化’实现集体智能的新方向。当前参数与特征平均等合并方法在面对经过微调而专门化的模型时表现不佳,因其内部特征表示产生表征分歧。随着模型向各自领域专业化,其特征空间结构的相似性下降,导致合并后在新任务上表现较差。我们使用中心核对齐(CKA)分析发现,模型专业化程度越高,特征空间的结构相似性越弱,阻碍了集体使用。为此,我们研究基于路由的合并策略,可动态跨层选择特征组合,相比固定层组合更具灵活性。然而,当模型内部层间表示不兼容时,该方法仍受限。结果表明,模型合并应设计于明确的输入输出空间,如同人类通过语言而非神经激活交流。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
In this work, we explore the limitations of combining models by averaging intermediate features, referred to as model merging, and propose a new direction for achieving collective model intelligence through what we call compatible specialization. Current methods for model merging, such as parameter and feature averaging, struggle to effectively combine specialized models due to representational divergence during fine-tuning. As models specialize to their individual domains, their internal feature representations become increasingly incompatible, leading to poor performance when attempting to merge them for new tasks. We analyze this phenomenon using centered kernel alignment (CKA) and show that as models specialize, the similarity in their feature space structure diminishes, hindering their capacity for collective use. To address these challenges, we investigate routing-based merging strategies, which offer more flexible methods for combining specialized models by dynamically routing across different layers. This allows us to improve on existing methods by combining features from multiple layers rather than relying on fixed, layer-wise combinations. However, we find that these approaches still face limitations when layers within models are representationally incompatible. Our findings highlight the importance of designing new approaches for model merging that operate on well-defined input and output spaces, similar to how humans communicate through language rather than intermediate neural activations.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。