医学影像模型在不同医院间表现下降?这篇综述梳理了应对分布偏移的四大策略。
Navigating Distribution Shifts in Medical Image Analysis: A Survey
- 按临床实际约束分类:联合训练、联邦学习、微调、领域泛化
- 数据越难获取,模型性能提升越受限,需更关注部署可行性
- 从对齐分布转向关注不确定性建模,强调真实场景可用性设计
医学图像分析(MedIA)在现代医疗中日益重要,助力临床诊断与个性化治疗。尽管深度学习(DL)技术取得显著进展,但其实际应用常受分布偏移影响——在特定数据集上训练的模型在不同医院或患者群体的数据上表现下降。为应对这一挑战,研究者们致力于提升模型在陌生环境中的适应能力。本文系统回顾了用于缓解分布偏移的深度学习方法,并不按技术特征分类,而是将现实临床约束(如数据访问受限、隐私要求严格、协作协议异构)与对应技术范式相连接。基于此,我们将现有工作分为联合训练、联邦学习、微调和领域泛化,每类对应特定医疗场景。此外,实证分析表明,随着域信息逐步不可用,性能提升愈发受限,且方法重心正从显式分布对齐转向不确定性感知建模,最终指向未来医学图像分析系统需更注重可部署性设计。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Medical Image Analysis (MedIA) has become indispensable in modern healthcare, enhancing clinical diagnostics and personalized treatment. Despite the remarkable advancements supported by deep learning (DL) technologies, their practical deployment faces challenges posed by distribution shifts, where models trained on specific datasets underperform on others from varying hospitals, or patient populations. To address this issue, researchers have been actively developing strategies to increase the adaptability of DL models, enabling their effective use in unfamiliar environments. This paper systematically reviews approaches that apply DL techniques to MedIA systems affected by distribution shifts. Rather than organizing existing methods by technical characteristics, we explicitly bridge real-world clinical constraints -- such as limited data accessibility, strict privacy requirements, and heterogeneous collaboration protocols -- with the technical paradigms able to address them. By establishing this connection between operational constraints and methodological evolution, we categorize existing works into Joint Training, Federated Learning, Fine-tuning, and Domain Generalization, each aligned with specific healthcare scenarios. Beyond this taxonomy, our empirical analysis suggests that, as domain information becomes progressively less accessible across these paradigms, performance improvements become increasingly constrained, and further uncovers a gradual shift in methodological focus from explicit distribution alignment toward uncertainty-aware modeling, ultimately pointing to the need for more deployability-aware design in real-world MedIA.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。