arXiv:2411.06877cs.IR2024-11中稿 · SIGIR 2025被引 25

用大模型辅助标注,省钱省时还更准。

LLM-Assisted Relevance Assessments: When Should We Ask LLMs for Help?

  • 根据大模型预测概率,选最值得人工标注的文档。
  • 在有限预算下,比纯人工或纯大模型评估更稳定可靠。
  • 适合资源紧张但需高质量评估的研究者使用。

测试集是信息检索研究中评估排序算法的重要工具,但其构建依赖大量人工标注,成本高、耗时长。当预算受限时,测试集规模小,导致评估结果不稳定。现有研究尝试用大语言模型(LLMs)完全替代人工标注,但其判断存在偏差且不完美,可靠性不足。本文提出 LLM 辅助相关性评估(LARA),在预算约束下平衡人工与大模型标注:利用大模型预测的相关性概率,选择最具价值的文档进行人工标注;通过理论推导,主动校准大模型的预测概率,学习校准模型;再用该模型对未标注数据进行去偏标注。在 TREC-7 Ad Hoc、TREC-8 Ad Hoc、TREC Robust 2004 与 TREC-COVID 数据集上的实验表明,LARA 在几乎所有预算条件下均优于其他方法,证明在相同人力投入下,合理利用大模型可显著提升评估效率与质量。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Test collections are information-retrieval tools that allow researchers to quickly and easily evaluate ranking algorithms. While test collections have become an integral part of IR research, the process of data creation involves significant manual-annotation effort, which often makes it very expensive and time-consuming. Consequently, test collections can become too small when the budget is limited, which may lead to unstable evaluations. As a cheaper alternative, recent studies have proposed using large language models (LLMs) to completely replace human assessors. However, while LLMs correlate to some extent with human judgments, their predictions are not perfect and often show bias. Thus, a complete replacement with LLMs is considered too risky and not fully reliable. In this paper, we propose LLM-Assisted Relevance Assessments (LARA), an effective method to balance manual annotations with LLM annotations, helping build a rich and reliable test collection even under a low budget. We use the LLM's predicted relevance probabilities to select the most profitable documents for manual annotation under a budget constraint. Guided by theoretical reasoning, LARA actively learns to calibrate the LLM's predicted relevance probabilities, directing the human-annotation process. Then, using the calibration model learned from the limited manual annotations, LARA debiases the LLM predictions to annotate the remaining non-assessed data. Experiments on TREC-7 Ad Hoc, TREC-8 Ad Hoc, TREC Robust 2004, and TREC-COVID datasets show that LARA outperforms alternative solutions under almost any budget constraint. While the community debates humans versus LLMs in relevance assessments, we contend that, given the same amount of human effort, it is reasonable to leverage LLMs.

信息检索大模型应用标注优化

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。