arXiv:2411.10475cs.HCcs.AI2024-11被引 4

研究司机如何判断列车碰撞风险,发现其会推理障碍物的意图和行为。

Beyond object identification: How train drivers evaluate the risk of collision

  • 通过图像访谈分析33名司机的判断依据
  • 对行人尤其关注其动作与心理状态
  • 结果可帮助提升人机协同安全系统

列车与障碍物相撞后果严重。为评估人工智能在防撞中的作用,需理解司机如何判断碰撞风险。本研究假设司机不仅识别障碍物,还基于所见情景进行推演。通过对33名司机进行基于图像的专家访谈,让他们评估碰撞风险并解释判断理由,同时设想情境变化如何影响风险。从口头报告中提取关于障碍物、环境或后果的概念,并归类为身份、位置、运动、行为、物理特征及心理状态等类别。结果显示,面对行人时,司机特别关注其行为与心理状态,并通过概念关联做出进一步推断,且推断方式随情境不同而异。研究强调,在提升人工与自动列车运行安全时,必须理解司机的风险评估机制。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

When trains collide with obstacles, the consequences are often severe. To assess how artificial intelligence might contribute to avoiding collisions, we need to understand how train drivers do it. What aspects of a situation do they consider when evaluating the risk of collision? In the present study, we assumed that train drivers do not only identify potential obstacles but interpret what they see in order to anticipate how the situation might unfold. However, to date it is unclear how exactly this is accomplished. Therefore, we assessed which cues train drivers use and what inferences they make. To this end, image-based expert interviews were conducted with 33 train drivers. Participants saw images with potential obstacles, rated the risk of collision, and explained their evaluation. Moreover, they were asked how the situation would need to change to decrease or increase collision risk. From their verbal reports, we extracted concepts about the potential obstacles, contexts, or consequences, and assigned these concepts to various categories (e.g., people's identity, location, movement, action, physical features, and mental states). The results revealed that especially for people, train drivers reason about their actions and mental states, and draw relations between concepts to make further inferences. These inferences systematically differ between situations. Our findings emphasise the need to understand train drivers' risk evaluation processes when aiming to enhance the safety of both human and automatic train operation.

人因分析安全评估决策推理

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。