系统梳理机器人手术的伦理争议,揭示七大核心议题。
The ethical landscape of robot-assisted surgery. A systematic review
- 通过系统综述分析66篇文献,归纳伦理争议框架
- 发现责任归属、医患关系、培训伦理等七类关键问题
- 适合医疗伦理、外科技术政策制定者参考
近年来,机器人辅助手术得到广泛应用,但相较于其他近距离接触脆弱患者群体的医疗技术,其伦理问题关注度较低。面对自动化程度持续提升可能带来的新挑战,本研究旨在系统梳理该领域的伦理讨论现状。研究在PROSPERO注册协议(CRD42023397951),于2023年1月检索Medline、EMBASE、CINAHL、Philosophers' Index、IEEE Xplorer、Web of Science、Scopus及Google Scholar数据库。由两名作者独立完成筛选、数据提取与分析,采用定性叙述综合方法。最终纳入66条记录,分析提炼出七个主要伦理议题:伤害与收益、责任与控制、医患关系、手术培训与学习中的伦理、公平性、转化问题以及经济考量。这些主题表明该领域存在广泛且复杂的伦理分歧,亟需审慎讨论并融入外科伦理体系。展望未来,我们主张应以更前瞻视角审视机器人手术设备,以应对自动化发展带来的潜在挑战。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Background: Robot-assisted surgery has been widely adopted in recent years. However, compared to other health technologies operating in close proximity to patients in a vulnerable state, ethical issues of robot-assisted surgery have received less attention. Against the background of increasing automation that are expected to raise new ethical issues, this systematic review aims to map the state of the ethical debate in this field. Methods: A protocol was registered in the international prospective register of systematic reviews (PROSPERO CRD42023397951). Medline via PubMed, EMBASE, CINHAL, Philosophers' Index, IEEE Xplorer, Web of Science (Core Collection), Scopus and Google Scholar were searched in January 2023. Screening, extraction, and analysis were conducted independently by two authors. A qualitative narrative synthesis was performed. Results: Out of 1,723 records, 66 records were included in the final dataset. Seven major strands of the ethical debate emerged during analysis. These include questions of harms and benefits, responsibility and control, professional-patient relationship, ethical issues in surgical training and learning, justice, translational questions, and economic considerations. Discussion: The identified themes testify to a broad range of different and differing ethical issues requiring careful deliberation and integration into the surgical ethos. Looking forward, we argue that a different perspective in addressing robotic surgical devices might be helpful to consider upcoming challenges of automation.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。