测试发现大模型看图时连基本几何信息都常搞错。
VisOnlyQA: Large Vision Language Models Still Struggle with Visual Perception of Geometric Information
- 构建新数据集VisOnlyQA,专测模型对形状角度大小的感知能力。
- 23个主流大模型在几何题上表现差,连GPT-4o也失误频发。
- 问题不在训练数据多寡,而是语言模型处理视觉信息能力弱。
大视觉语言模型(LVLM)在多种跨模态任务中表现优异,但其对图像中视觉信息的准确理解仍不清晰。尤其对形状、角度、尺寸等几何属性的感知能力尚未充分评估,而这些属性对需要精细视觉理解的任务至关重要。本文提出VisOnlyQA数据集,用于评测LVLM的几何感知能力。该数据集包含12类任务,直接考察模型对几何图形、图表、化学结构和3D形状中的几何信息的理解。实验发现:(i) 当前最先进的23个LVLM(包括GPT-4o和Gemini 2.5 Pro)在几何感知任务上表现不佳;(ii) 在VisOnlyQA训练集上微调并不能稳定提升性能,即使在分布内任务上亦然;(iii) 语言模型(LLM)可能是瓶颈——使用更强语言模型的LVLM在无复杂推理需求下表现更好,说明视觉编码器输出的信息处理方式存在缺陷。数据集、代码与模型响应已开源。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Large Vision Language Models (LVLMs) have achieved remarkable performance in various vision-language tasks. However, it is still unclear how accurately LVLMs can perceive visual information in images. In particular, the capability of LVLMs to perceive geometric information, such as shape, angle, and size, remains insufficiently analyzed, although the perception of these properties is crucial for tasks that require a detailed visual understanding. In this work, we introduce VisOnlyQA, a dataset for evaluating the geometric perception of LVLMs, and reveal that LVLMs often cannot accurately perceive basic geometric information in images, while human performance is nearly perfect. VisOnlyQA consists of 12 tasks that directly ask about geometric information in geometric shapes, charts, chemical structures, and 3D shapes. Our experiments highlight the following findings: (i) State-of-the-art LVLMs struggle with basic geometric perception. 23 LVLMs we evaluate, including GPT-4o and Gemini 2.5 Pro, work poorly on VisOnlyQA. (ii) Additional training data does not resolve this issue. Fine-tuning on the training set of VisOnlyQA is not always effective, even for in-distribution tasks. (iii) LLM may be the bottleneck. LVLMs using stronger LLMs exhibit better geometric perception on VisOnlyQA, while it does not require complex reasoning, suggesting that the way LVLMs process information from visual encoders is a bottleneck. The datasets, code, and model responses are provided at https://github.com/psunlpgroup/VisOnlyQA.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。