发现多模态训练会削弱语言模型推理能力,提出无需训练的修复方法。
Training-Free Mitigation of Language Reasoning Degradation After Multimodal Instruction Tuning
- 对比原始模型与多模态适配后的性能,发现不同模型影响各异。
- 多模态训练使Mistral语言推理下降,但提升常识推理;数学推理普遍退化。
- 提出无需训练的模型融合法,可修复推理退化并提升视觉任务表现。
多模态模型通常将大型语言模型(LLM)与视觉编码器结合,并通过指令微调在多模态数据上进行训练。尽管这一过程使LLM适应多模态场景,但其对原始语言推理能力的影响尚不明确。本文以领先的多模态框架LLaVA为例,将Vicuna或Mistral等LLM与CLIP视觉编码器结合,对比其原始版本与多模态适配版本在八项语言推理任务上的表现。实验显示:多模态学习对Vicuna和Mistral的影响不同——多数任务中Mistral出现推理退化,而Vicuna表现提升;数学推理任务(如GSM8K)性能普遍下降,但常识推理任务(如CommonsenseQA)有所增强。此外,本文提出一种无需训练的模型融合技术,能有效缓解多模态适配后Mistral的语言推理退化,甚至提升视觉任务表现。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Multimodal models typically combine a powerful large language model (LLM) with a vision encoder and are then trained on multimodal data via instruction tuning. While this process adapts LLMs to multimodal settings, it remains unclear whether this adaptation compromises their original language reasoning capabilities. In this work, we explore the effects of multimodal instruction tuning on language reasoning performance. We focus on LLaVA, a leading multimodal framework that integrates LLMs such as Vicuna or Mistral with the CLIP vision encoder. We compare the performance of the original LLMs with their multimodal-adapted counterparts across eight language reasoning tasks. Our experiments yield several key insights. First, the impact of multimodal learning varies between Vicuna and Mistral: we observe a degradation in language reasoning for Mistral but improvements for Vicuna across most tasks. Second, while multimodal instruction learning consistently degrades performance on mathematical reasoning tasks (e.g., GSM8K), it enhances performance on commonsense reasoning tasks (e.g., CommonsenseQA). Finally, we demonstrate that a training-free model merging technique can effectively mitigate the language reasoning degradation observed in multimodal-adapted Mistral and even improve performance on visual tasks.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。