arXiv:2412.08610cs.GTcs.AI2024-12被引 13

竞争能促使生成式AI产出更多样内容,避免同质化

Competition and Diversity in Generative AI

  • 用博弈论模型分析竞争如何激励内容创新
  • 实验显示竞争环境下语言模型答案更独特,多样性提升
  • 适合关注AI生态多样性与市场机制的研究者

近期实验室和现实中的证据表明,生成式人工智能的使用降低了内容多样性,相同或相似模型导致行为趋同。本文观察到相反力量:竞争。当生产者为用户或注意力竞争时,会激励其创造新颖或独特内容。通过形式化博弈论模型,我们发现竞争市场会选择多样化的人工智能模型,缓解单一化问题。进一步发现,一个在孤立测试中表现优异的生成式模型,在竞争环境中可能无法创造价值。结果强调必须全面评估生成式AI模型输出分布的广度,尤其在部署于竞争环境时。我们通过语言模型玩单词游戏Scattergories进行实证验证,玩家因正确且独特的答案获得奖励。总体结果表明,生成式AI导致的同质化在竞争市场中难以持续,反而可能推动AI模型开发向多元化发展。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Recent evidence, both in the lab and in the wild, suggests that the use of generative artificial intelligence reduces the diversity of content produced. The use of the same or similar AI models appears to lead to more homogeneous behavior. Our work begins with the observation that there is a force pushing in the opposite direction: competition. When producers compete with one another (e.g., for customers or attention), they are incentivized to create novel or unique content. We explore the impact competition has on both content diversity and overall social welfare. Through a formal game-theoretic model, we show that competitive markets select for diverse AI models, mitigating monoculture. We further show that a generative AI model that performs well in isolation (i.e., according to a benchmark) may fail to provide value in a competitive market. Our results highlight the importance of evaluating generative AI models across the breadth of their output distributions, particularly when they will be deployed in competitive environments. We validate our results empirically by using language models to play Scattergories, a word game in which players are rewarded for answers that are both correct and unique. Overall, our results suggest that homogenization due to generative AI is unlikely to persist in competitive markets, and instead, competition in downstream markets may drive diversification in AI model development.

生成式AI多样性竞争机制

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。