arXiv:2412.14133cs.CL2024-12ACL被引 13

视觉模型识记实体能力弱于文本,图像信息传递效率低

Performance Gap in Entity Knowledge Extraction Across Modalities in Vision Language Models

  • 用新数据集分离识别与问答,对比图文回答准确率
  • 图像描述下准确率下降达18%,部分模型表现显著下滑
  • 发现深层才有效传递图像信息,中层处理关键却留白少

视觉语言模型(VLMs)在从图像中提取和推理信息方面表现出色,但其对特定实体的内部知识利用能力仍待探索。本文研究了模型在回答关于文本描述实体的问题与图像呈现实体的问题时的表现差异。结果表明,当实体以图像形式呈现时,某些模型的准确率下降高达18%。为此,我们提出了PopVQA数据集,可分离实体识别与问题回答任务,并用于评测多个模型。我们推测该性能差距源于图像标记到查询标记的信息流限制。通过机制可解释性工具发现:尽管图像标记经视觉编码器预处理,但有意义的信息传递仅发生在模型更深层;此外,关键图像处理发生在语言模型中层,导致可用于连续推理的层数极少,暴露出模型在推理中层使用效率上的潜在不足。这些发现揭示了VLM内部机制,为提升其推理能力提供了方向。PopVQA 数据集可在 https://huggingface.co/datasets/idoco/PopVQA 获取。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Vision-language models (VLMs) excel at extracting and reasoning about information from images. Yet, their capacity to leverage internal knowledge about specific entities remains underexplored. This work investigates the disparity in model performance when answering factual questions about an entity described in text versus depicted in an image. Our results reveal a significant accuracy drop - reaching 18% for some models - when the entity is presented visually instead of textually. To study this gap we present PopVQA, a dataset which allows separating entity recognition and question answering, and use it to benchmark several models. We hypothesize that this decline arises from limitations in how information flows from image tokens to query tokens. Thus, we use mechanistic interpretability tools to reveal that, although image tokens are preprocessed by the vision encoder, meaningful information flow from these tokens occurs only in the much deeper layers. Furthermore, critical image processing happens in the language model's middle layers, allowing few layers for consecutive reasoning, highlighting a potential inefficiency in how the model utilizes its layers for reasoning. These insights shed light on the internal mechanics of VLMs and offer pathways for enhancing their reasoning capabilities. PopVQA can be found at https://huggingface.co/datasets/idoco/PopVQA.

视觉语言模型知识提取可解释性

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。