揭示了模型递归训练中崩溃速率,发现简单分布下遗忘需极长时间。
Rate of Model Collapse in Recursive Training
- 基于最大似然估计分析递归训练中的模型崩溃速率。
- 离散分布中遗忘时间与词频线性相关,高斯模型标准差约在n轮后归零。
- 理论结合实验,适用于研究模型长期稳定性与合成数据风险的人群。
由于从机器学习模型生成合成数据的便利性,新模型可能基于前序模型生成的数据进行训练。这种递归训练过程引发了对模型质量长期影响的担忧。随着模型在前一轮生成的数据上不断训练,其捕捉原始人类生成数据细微特征的能力可能下降,这被称为‘模型崩溃’。本文探讨了在最大似然(ML)或近似最大似然估计下,若干经典分布族在递归训练中的模型崩溃速率。令人惊讶的是,即使对于离散分布和高斯分布这类基础分布,其崩溃速率仍未知。本文首次在这些基本设定下理论刻画了崩溃速率,并辅以实验验证。结果表明:对于离散分布,遗忘一个词所需时间大致与该词在原始语料中出现次数成线性关系;对于高斯模型,标准差约在 $n$ 次迭代后趋于零,其中 $n$ 为每轮迭代的样本数。这两项发现表明,在近似最大似然估计且样本量充足的情况下,模型遗忘过程至少在这些简单分布中将持续很长时间。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Given the ease of creating synthetic data from machine learning models, new models can be potentially trained on synthetic data generated by previous models. This recursive training process raises concerns about the long-term impact on model quality. As models are recursively trained on generated data from previous rounds, their ability to capture the nuances of the original human-generated data may degrade. This is often referred to as \emph{model collapse}. In this work, we ask how fast model collapse occurs for some well-studied distribution families under maximum likelihood (ML or near ML) estimation during recursive training. Surprisingly, even for fundamental distributions such as discrete and Gaussian distributions, the exact rate of model collapse is unknown. In this work, we theoretically characterize the rate of collapse in these fundamental settings and complement it with experimental evaluations. Our results show that for discrete distributions, the time to forget a word is approximately linearly dependent on the number of times it occurred in the original corpus, and for Gaussian models, the standard deviation reduces to zero roughly at $n$ iterations, where $n$ is the number of samples at each iteration. Both of these findings imply that model forgetting, at least in these simple distributions under near ML estimation with many samples, takes a long time.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。