提出新框架,解析多模态沟通中意义与语用的动态对齐机制
A Metasemantic-Metapragmatic Framework for Taxonomizing Multimodal Communicative Alignment
- 基于皮尔士三类表征,构建感知、语境、符号三元动态框架
- 提出语境化方向性原则,揭示跨模式沟通的语用转换路径
- 强调语用层面的重要性,适合人机交互与认知计算研究者
本文基于当代实用主义哲学与认知语言学理论,提出一个动态的元语义-元语用分类框架,用于理解和建模类人多模态沟通对齐。该框架以美国逻辑学家兼实用主义哲学家查尔斯·桑德斯·皮尔士最初提出的三种基本沟通能力为基础:象似性(感官与感知特性)、指示性(语境与社会文化关联)和规则性(符号与直觉推理)。在此基础上,本文引入“指示性语境化”概念,并提出“语境化方向性”原则,用以刻画在多模态沟通中维持、导航或切换语义与语用模式的关键元语用能力。作者指出,当前认知-社会计算与工程方法过度侧重语义/元语义领域,忽视了元语用指示性在跨越语义-语用谱系中的核心作用。框架还探讨了其在意图性、身份、情感及伦理方面对同模态与跨模态人机对齐的深远影响。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Drawing on contemporary pragmatist philosophy and linguistic theories on cognition, meaning, and communication, this paper presents a dynamic, metasemantic-metapragmatic taxonomy for grounding and conceptualizing human-like multimodal communicative alignment. The framework is rooted in contemporary developments of the three basic communicative capacities initially identified by American logician and pragmatist philosopher Charles Sanders Peirce: iconic (sensory and perceptual qualities), indexical (contextual and sociocultural associations), and rule-like (symbolic and intuitive reasoning). Expanding on these developments, I introduce the concept of indexical contextualization and propose the principle of "contextualization directionality" for characterizing the crucial metapragmatic capacity for maintaining, navigating, or transitioning between semantic and pragmatic modes of multimodal communication. I contend that current cognitive-social computational and engineering methodologies disproportionately emphasize the semantic/metasemantic domain, overlooking the pivotal role of metapragmatic indexicality in traversing the semantic-pragmatic spectrum of communication. The framework's broader implications for intentionality, identity, affect, and ethics in within-modal and cross-modal human-machine alignment are also discussed.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。