用自提问测试评估大模型真理解能力,发现解释与答题常不一致。
Explain-Query-Test: Self-Evaluating LLMs Via Explanation and Comprehension Discrepancy
- 让模型先解释主题,再自动生成问题并作答,形成闭环评估链。
- 生成问题的准确率与MMLU-Pro表现高度相关,可预测模型水平。
- 解释能力强但答题差,暴露当前大模型知识表征的深层缺陷。
大型语言模型在生成复杂概念的详细且连贯解释方面表现出色,但其对所阐述内容的真实理解程度仍不明确。为评估模型与其生成内容之间的理解水平,我们构建了一个自评估流程:(i) 给定主题生成相关内容片段;(ii) 基于该片段生成问答对;(iii) 针对问题生成答案。此方法称为解释-提问-测试(Explain-Query-Test, EQT)。有趣的是,运行EQT流程生成的问题回答准确率与典型基准如MMLU-Pro的表现强相关,表明EQT具有预测模型性能的能力,且无需外部评价数据,仅需感兴趣的主题列表即可对模型进行排序。此外,结果揭示了模型生成详尽解释与相关问题回答之间存在差距,突显了当前大模型在内部知识表示与推理能力上的根本局限。代码已开源:https://github.com/asgsaeid/EQT。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable proficiency in generating detailed and coherent explanations of complex concepts. However, the extent to which these models truly comprehend the concepts they articulate remains unclear. To assess the level of comprehension of a model relative to the content it generates, we implemented a self-evaluation pipeline where models: (i) given a topic generate an excerpt with information about the topic, (ii) given an excerpt generate question-answer pairs, and finally (iii) given a question generate an answer. We refer to this self-evaluation approach as Explain-Query-Test (EQT). Interestingly, the accuracy on generated questions resulting from running the EQT pipeline correlates strongly with the model performance as verified by typical benchmarks such as MMLU-Pro. In other words, EQT's performance is predictive of MMLU-Pro's, and EQT can be used to rank models without the need for any external source of evaluation data other than lists of topics of interest. Moreover, our results reveal a disparity between the models' ability to produce detailed explanations and their performance on questions related to those explanations. This gap highlights fundamental limitations in the internal knowledge representation and reasoning abilities of current LLMs. We release the code at https://github.com/asgsaeid/EQT.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。