arXiv:2501.19178cs.LG2025-01被引 4

用机制引导的半机理模型,提升基因表达预测效果

No Foundations without Foundations -- Why semi-mechanistic models are essential for regulatory biology

  • 构建跨体外与体内实验的半机理框架,统一扰动设计
  • 发现现有机器学习方法隐藏假设,改进损失函数提升性能
  • 适合关注生物机制建模与实验设计的科研人员

尽管投入巨大,深度学习在解析调控生物学方面仍未带来突破性进展,尤其在预测基因表达谱方面表现有限。本文认为,若不结合机制洞察与严谨实验设计,真正的调控生物学‘基础模型’将难以实现。我们提出一种自下而上的半机理框架,统一了体外与体内CRISPR筛选中的扰动实验设计,适用于分化与非分化细胞系统。该框架揭示了现有机器学习方法中未被识别的隐含假设,并阐明其与变分自编码器、结构因果模型等技术的联系。实践中,该框架建议改进损失函数,可显著提升预测性能;同时提供误差分析指导批处理策略。由于细胞调控源于大量未知分子组件间的复杂互作,仅靠结构生物学无法实现系统理解。真正进步需从第一性原理出发,思考实验如何捕捉生物现象、数据如何生成,并在模型架构中忠实反映这些过程。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Despite substantial efforts, deep learning has not yet delivered a transformative impact on elucidating regulatory biology, particularly in the realm of predicting gene expression profiles. Here, we argue that genuine "foundation models" of regulatory biology will remain out of reach unless guided by frameworks that integrate mechanistic insight with principled experimental design. We present one such ground-up, semi-mechanistic framework that unifies perturbation-based experimental designs across both in vitro and in vivo CRISPR screens, accounting for differentiating and non-differentiating cellular systems. By revealing previously unrecognised assumptions in published machine learning methods, our approach clarifies links with popular techniques such as variational autoencoders and structural causal models. In practice, this framework suggests a modified loss function that we demonstrate can improve predictive performance, and further suggests an error analysis that informs batching strategies. Ultimately, since cellular regulation emerges from innumerable interactions amongst largely uncharted molecular components, we contend that systems-level understanding cannot be achieved through structural biology alone. Instead, we argue that real progress will require a first-principles perspective on how experiments capture biological phenomena, how data are generated, and how these processes can be reflected in more faithful modelling architectures.

机制建模基因调控CRISPR筛选

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。