arXiv:2502.06341cs.CVcs.AI2025-02被引 1

研究发现面部识别技术对唐氏综合征人群准确率低,且易传播刻板印象。

Facial Analysis Systems and Down Syndrome

  • 构建唐氏综合征人脸数据集,对比正常人组测试三类任务
  • 男性患者性别识别错误率高,成人常被误判为儿童
  • 技术会放大社会偏见,适合关注算法公平性的研究者阅读

近年来,面部分析技术的伦理、社会与法律问题备受关注。批评者指出,这些技术可能加剧对边缘群体的偏见与歧视。本文聚焦于唐氏综合征人群这一长期被忽视的脆弱群体,构建了一个包含唐氏综合征患者和非患者人脸的专用数据集,并使用两种商业工具在性别识别、年龄预测和人脸标注三个任务上进行测试。结果表明:实验组整体预测准确率较低;男性唐氏综合征患者性别识别错误率显著升高;成年患者常被误标为儿童;社会刻板印象在两组中均有体现——女性更常关联外貌标签,男性更常关联教育与能力标签。这些发现揭示了该技术在特定人群中存在的系统性偏差,证实其性能高度依赖训练数据分布。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

The ethical, social and legal issues surrounding facial analysis technologies have been widely debated in recent years. Key critics have argued that these technologies can perpetuate bias and discrimination, particularly against marginalized groups. We contribute to this field of research by reporting on the limitations of facial analysis systems with the faces of people with Down syndrome: this particularly vulnerable group has received very little attention in the literature so far. This study involved the creation of a specific dataset of face images. An experimental group with faces of people with Down syndrome, and a control group with faces of people who are not affected by the syndrome. Two commercial tools were tested on the dataset, along three tasks: gender recognition, age prediction and face labelling. The results show an overall lower accuracy of prediction in the experimental group, and other specific patterns of performance differences: i) high error rates in gender recognition in the category of males with Down syndrome; ii) adults with Down syndrome were more often incorrectly labelled as children; iii) social stereotypes are propagated in both the control and experimental groups, with labels related to aesthetics more often associated with women, and labels related to education level and skills more often associated with men. These results, although limited in scope, shed new light on the biases that alter face classification when applied to faces of people with Down syndrome. They confirm the structural limitation of the technology, which is inherently dependent on the datasets used to train the models.

面部识别算法偏见唐氏综合征

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。