arXiv:2503.02199cs.CVcs.AI2025-03CVPR被引 90

发现视觉语言模型过度信任文本,导致识别错误。

Words or Vision: Do Vision-Language Models Have Blind Faith in Text?

  • 通过文本扰动测试,发现模型在图文不一致时更信文本。
  • 文本损坏时模型准确率下降超30%,暴露安全风险。
  • 微调加文本增强可缓解偏见,适合做多模态系统设计者。

视觉语言模型(VLMs)在视觉任务中能融合视觉与文本信息,但对模态不一致的处理机制尚未深入研究。本文在四种视觉中心任务中引入文本变体,评估十种VLMs,发现存在“盲信文本”现象:当图文不一致时,模型过度依赖文本信息,导致在文本受损情况下性能显著下降。我们分析了影响该偏见的因素,包括指令提示、语言模型规模、文本相关性、词元顺序以及视觉与文本确定性之间的相互作用。尽管扩大语言模型规模可轻微缓解偏见,但词元顺序等由语言模型继承的位置偏差可能加剧问题。通过引入带文本增强的监督微调,有效降低了文本偏倚。理论分析表明,该现象可能源于训练阶段纯文本与多模态数据比例失衡。研究强调需平衡训练数据并重视模态间交互,以提升VLM在多模态不一致场景下的鲁棒性与可靠性。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Vision-Language Models (VLMs) excel in integrating visual and textual information for vision-centric tasks, but their handling of inconsistencies between modalities is underexplored. We investigate VLMs' modality preferences when faced with visual data and varied textual inputs in vision-centered settings. By introducing textual variations to four vision-centric tasks and evaluating ten Vision-Language Models (VLMs), we discover a \emph{``blind faith in text''} phenomenon: VLMs disproportionately trust textual data over visual data when inconsistencies arise, leading to significant performance drops under corrupted text and raising safety concerns. We analyze factors influencing this text bias, including instruction prompts, language model size, text relevance, token order, and the interplay between visual and textual certainty. While certain factors, such as scaling up the language model size, slightly mitigate text bias, others like token order can exacerbate it due to positional biases inherited from language models. To address this issue, we explore supervised fine-tuning with text augmentation and demonstrate its effectiveness in reducing text bias. Additionally, we provide a theoretical analysis suggesting that the blind faith in text phenomenon may stem from an imbalance of pure text and multi-modal data during training. Our findings highlight the need for balanced training and careful consideration of modality interactions in VLMs to enhance their robustness and reliability in handling multi-modal data inconsistencies.

视觉语言模型多模态文本偏见鲁棒性

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。