AI与同行反馈能提升哈萨克学者的论文写作能力,尤其在方法论上更依赖人审。
The impact of AI and peer feedback on research writing skills: a study using the CGScholar platform among Kazakhstani scholars
- 通过CGScholar平台对比AI工具与同行互评对写作的影响
- 熟悉AI者更愿采纳反馈,有经验者更期待同行方法指导
- 适合关注学术写作改进与人机协同的科研人员参考
本研究基于伊利诺伊大学厄本那-香槟分校(UIUC)开发的CGScholar平台,探讨人工智能与同行反馈对哈萨克斯坦学者学术写作能力的影响。研究对象为36名参与教育领域科学实习项目的学者,采用中英文双语的谷歌表单收集数据,包含15道选择题、量表题及开放题。结果显示,对AI工具越熟悉,越愿意根据反馈修改论文;研究写作经验越丰富,越期望同行在研究方法方面提供反馈。尽管学者们对AI辅助反馈持开放态度,但对同行尤其是方法论建议仍高度重视。研究证明,在学术环境中融合AI工具与传统反馈机制,有助于提升论文质量。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
This research studies the impact of AI and peer feedback on the academic writing development of Kazakhstani scholars using the CGScholar platform - a product of research into collaborative learning, big data, and artificial intelligence developed by educators and computer scientists at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign (UIUC). The study aimed to find out how familiarity with AI tools and peer feedback processes impacts participants' openness to incorporating feedback into their academic writing. The study involved 36 scholars enrolled in a scientific internship focused on education at UIUC. A survey with 15 multiple-choice questions, a Likert scale, and open-ended questions was used to collect data. The survey was conducted via Google Forms in both English and Russian to ensure linguistic accessibility. Demographic information such as age, gender, and first language was collected to provide a detailed understanding of the data. The analysis revealed a moderate positive correlation between familiarity with AI tools and openness to making changes based on feedback, and a strong positive correlation between research writing experience and expectations of peer feedback, especially in the area of research methodology. These results show that participants are open-minded to AI-assisted feedback; however, they still highly appreciate peer input, especially regarding methodological guidance. This study demonstrates the potential benefits of integrating AI tools with traditional feedback mechanisms to improve research writing quality in academic settings.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。