深度学习追踪方法高估事故风险,实则让道路安全显得更差。
How good are deep learning methods for automated road safety analysis using video data? An experimental study
- 用三套追踪算法分析交通视频,结合后处理优化轨迹
- 所有方法均高估交互次数且低估碰撞时间,误判安全性
- 适合关注自动驾驶感知可靠性的研究者与工程师
基于图像的多目标检测(MOD)与多目标追踪(MOT)技术快速发展,2D和3D方法已广泛应用于单目与双目摄像头。道路安全分析可借助这些进展,通过提取道路使用者轨迹计算安全指标如碰撞前时间(TTC)和事后侵入时间(PET)。本文在标注的KITTI交通视频数据集上测试三种MOT方法,包括一种基于双目相机的方法,并引入两个后处理步骤(IDsplit和SS)以改善追踪结果并分析影响TTC的因素。实验表明,尽管某些方法在交互数量或TTC分布相似性上表现较好,但所有方法均系统性地高估交互次数、低估TTC,导致判断出的交互更频繁且更严重,使实际安全状况被误判为更危险。未来将拓展更多方法与数据,尤其是来自路边传感器的数据,以验证结果并提升性能。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Image-based multi-object detection (MOD) and multi-object tracking (MOT) are advancing at a fast pace. A variety of 2D and 3D MOD and MOT methods have been developed for monocular and stereo cameras. Road safety analysis can benefit from those advancements. As crashes are rare events, surrogate measures of safety (SMoS) have been developed for safety analyses. (Semi-)Automated safety analysis methods extract road user trajectories to compute safety indicators, for example, Time-to-Collision (TTC) and Post-encroachment Time (PET). Inspired by the success of deep learning in MOD and MOT, we investigate three MOT methods, including one based on a stereo-camera, using the annotated KITTI traffic video dataset. Two post-processing steps, IDsplit and SS, are developed to improve the tracking results and investigate the factors influencing the TTC. The experimental results show that, despite some advantages in terms of the numbers of interactions or similarity to the TTC distributions, all the tested methods systematically over-estimate the number of interactions and under-estimate the TTC: they report more interactions and more severe interactions, making the road user interactions appear less safe than they are. Further efforts will be directed towards testing more methods and more data, in particular from roadside sensors, to verify the results and improve the performance.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。