用内容预测题难易度,让大模型评估又快又准。
Reliable and Efficient Amortized Model-based Evaluation
- 用模型预测题目难度,摆脱人工标注。
- 在22个基准上测试,比传统方法更可靠。
- 适合需要频繁评估大模型的团队使用。
语言模型在开发和部署阶段需进行全面评估,因其具备数学推理、法律支持、医疗诊断等能力,也存在种族偏见、毒性言论和误导信息等安全风险。当前广泛采用的平均分指标因依赖大量基准题而成本高昂,常因子集题目难度不均导致结果不可靠。项目响应理论(IRT)可控制题目难度以提升可靠性,但估计难度代价高。本文训练一个基于内容的难度预测模型,实现低成本可靠评估;并进一步利用该模型构建难度可控的问题生成器,支持自适应测试——根据模型当前表现动态选择最有信息量的题目。在22个常见自然语言基准与172个语言模型上的实验表明,该方法相比现有实践更具可靠性与效率。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Comprehensive evaluations of language models (LM) during both development and deployment phases are necessary because these models possess numerous capabilities (e.g., mathematical reasoning, legal support, or medical diagnostic) as well as safety risks (e.g., racial bias, toxicity, or misinformation). The average score across a wide range of benchmarks provides a signal that helps guide the use of these LMs in practice. Currently, holistic evaluations are costly due to the large volume of benchmark questions, making frequent evaluations impractical. A popular attempt to lower the cost is to compute the average score on a subset of the benchmark. This approach, unfortunately, often renders an unreliable measure of LM performance because the average score is often confounded with the difficulty of the questions in the benchmark subset. Item response theory (IRT) was designed to address this challenge, providing a reliable measurement by careful controlling for question difficulty. Unfortunately, question difficulty is expensive to estimate. Facing this challenge, we train a model that predicts question difficulty from its content, enabling a reliable measurement at a fraction of the cost. In addition, we leverage this difficulty predictor to further improve the evaluation efficiency through training a question generator given a difficulty level. This question generator is essential in adaptive testing, where, instead of using a random subset of the benchmark questions, informative questions are adaptively chosen based on the current estimation of LLM performance. Experiments on 22 common natural language benchmarks and 172 LMs show that this approach is more reliable and efficient compared to current common practice.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。