用视觉提示评估视频理解,更贴近真实人机交互场景。
V2P-Bench: Evaluating Video-Language Understanding with Visual Prompts for Better Human-Model Interaction
- 引入视觉提示替代文本提示,提升模型与用户交互效率。
- 模型对视觉提示的零样本理解能力有限,时空理解仍差(o1仅71.8%)。
- 发现模型普遍存在‘作弊现象’,长视频和低采样率下性能虚高。
大视觉语言模型在视频理解领域取得显著进展,但现有基准大多依赖文本提示,常需复杂指代语言,降低人机交互的准确性和效率。为此,我们提出V2P-Bench,一个面向人机交互场景的视频视觉提示理解评估基准。该基准包含980个视频和1172个高质量问答对,每对均配有手工标注的视觉提示帧,覆盖三大任务、十二个类别,支持细粒度实例级评估。分析表明:1)视觉提示在交互中更友好,显著提升模型表现与用户体验;2)模型具备一定零样本理解能力,但时空理解能力不足,o1仅达71.8%,远低于人类专家的88.3%,多数开源模型低于60%;3)视频问答任务中普遍存在‘作弊现象’,随视频变长、帧采样密度降低而加剧,人为虚高性能评分。V2P-Bench有望揭示挑战并推动人机交互与视频理解评估发展。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) have made significant strides in the field of video understanding in recent times. Nevertheless, existing video benchmarks predominantly rely on text prompts for evaluation, which often require complex referential language and diminish both the accuracy and efficiency of human model interaction in turn. To address this limitation, we propose V2P-Bench, a robust and comprehensive benchmark for evaluating the ability of LVLMs to understand Video Visual Prompts in human model interaction scenarios. V2P-Bench consists of 980 videos and 1172 well-structured high-quality QA pairs, each paired with manually annotated visual prompt frames. The benchmark spans three main tasks and twelve categories, thereby enabling fine-grained, instance-level evaluation. Through an in-depth analysis of current LVLMs, we identify several key findings: 1) Visual prompts are both more model-friendly and user-friendly in interactive scenarios than text prompts, leading to significantly improved model performance and enhanced user experience. 2) Models are reasonably capable of zero-shot understanding of visual prompts, but struggle with spatiotemporal understanding. Even o1 achieves only 71.8%, far below the human expert score of 88.3%, while most open-source models perform below 60%. 3) LVLMs exhibit pervasive Hack Phenomena in video question answering tasks, which become more pronounced as video length increases and frame sampling density decreases, thereby inflating performance scores artificially. We anticipate that V2P-Bench will not only shed light on these challenges but also serve as a foundational tool for advancing human model interaction and improving the evaluation of video understanding.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。