arXiv:2503.22420cs.CV2025-03CVPR被引 29

提出新基准Beacon3D,破解3D视觉语言模型评估难题

Unveiling the Mist over 3D Vision-Language Understanding: Object-centric Evaluation with Chain-of-Analysis

  • 以物体为中心设计测试,每物体多轮验证提升可靠性
  • 发现当前模型在问答任务中泛化能力差,且推理与定位不一致
  • 揭示大语言模型虽流行但削弱定位能力,适合研究评估方法者

现有3D视觉-语言(3D-VL)评测基准在评估模型时存在三大缺陷:测试数据模糊、指标过于简化且割裂定位与问答任务。为此,我们提出Beacon3D基准,包含高质量自然语言数据、物体中心评估机制及链式分析范式,实现对定位与问答一致性的联合评估。在Beacon3D上对主流3D-VL模型的评估显示:(1)物体中心评估揭示了模型在问答任务中的真实性能与弱泛化能力;(2)当前模型的定位-问答一致性仍脆弱;(3)引入大语言模型虽常见,却损害定位能力,未能显著提升问答表现。该工作推动3D-VL评估向更可信方向发展。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Existing 3D vision-language (3D-VL) benchmarks fall short in evaluating 3D-VL models, creating a "mist" that obscures rigorous insights into model capabilities and 3D-VL tasks. This mist persists due to three key limitations. First, flawed test data, like ambiguous referential text in the grounding task, can yield incorrect and unreliable test results. Second, oversimplified metrics such as simply averaging accuracy per question answering (QA) pair, cannot reveal true model capability due to their vulnerability to language variations. Third, existing benchmarks isolate the grounding and QA tasks, disregarding the underlying coherence that QA should be based on solid grounding capabilities. To unveil the "mist", we propose Beacon3D, a benchmark for 3D-VL grounding and QA tasks, delivering a perspective shift in the evaluation of 3D-VL understanding. Beacon3D features (i) high-quality test data with precise and natural language, (ii) object-centric evaluation with multiple tests per object to ensure robustness, and (iii) a novel chain-of-analysis paradigm to address language robustness and model performance coherence across grounding and QA. Our evaluation of state-of-the-art 3D-VL models on Beacon3D reveals that (i) object-centric evaluation elicits true model performance and particularly weak generalization in QA; (ii) grounding-QA coherence remains fragile in current 3D-VL models, and (iii) incorporating large language models (LLMs) to 3D-VL models, though as a prevalent practice, hinders grounding capabilities and has yet to elevate QA capabilities. We hope Beacon3D and our comprehensive analysis could benefit the 3D-VL community towards faithful developments.

3D-VL评估基准链式分析

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。