arXiv:2503.22454cs.LGcs.AI2025-03

提出因果框架,量化并缓解贷款等决策中的非二元待遇歧视

A Causal Framework to Measure and Mitigate Non-binary Treatment Discrimination

  • 构建因果模型,区分个体特征与非二元处理决策(如贷款条件)
  • 在4个真实贷款数据集上发现非二元决策存在差异,影响还款结果
  • 可通过干预处理决策,减轻历史不公平,提升风险评估公平性

算法公平性研究常将复杂决策(如保释或贷款审批)简化为二分类任务,但忽视了其中非二元处理决策(如保释条件或贷款条款)对下游结果(如还款或再犯)的影响。本文主张非二元处理决策是决策过程的核心,且由决策者控制,应纳入公平性分析。我们提出一个因果框架,明确区分决策对象的协变量与处理决策,使决策者能(i)在历史数据中测量处理差异及其下游影响,(ii)通过反事实推理,在自动化决策中减轻过去不公平处理的影响。我们在4个广泛使用的贷款审批数据集上实证分析,揭示非二元处理决策中的潜在不平等及其对结果的歧视性影响,强调必须将处理决策纳入公平评估。此外,通过干预处理决策,我们的框架有效缓解了历史数据中的处理歧视,确保风险评分和非二元决策过程对所有利益相关方更公平。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Fairness studies of algorithmic decision-making systems often simplify complex decision processes, such as bail or loan approvals, into binary classification tasks. However, these approaches overlook that such decisions are not inherently binary (e.g., approve or not approve bail or loan); they also involve non-binary treatment decisions (e.g., bail conditions or loan terms) that can influence the downstream outcomes (e.g., loan repayment or reoffending). In this paper, we argue that non-binary treatment decisions are integral to the decision process and controlled by decision-makers and, therefore, should be central to fairness analyses in algorithmic decision-making. We propose a causal framework that extends fairness analyses and explicitly distinguishes between decision-subjects' covariates and the treatment decisions. This specification allows decision-makers to use our framework to (i) measure treatment disparity and its downstream effects in historical data and, using counterfactual reasoning, (ii) mitigate the impact of past unfair treatment decisions when automating decision-making. We use our framework to empirically analyze four widely used loan approval datasets to reveal potential disparity in non-binary treatment decisions and their discriminatory impact on outcomes, highlighting the need to incorporate treatment decisions in fairness assessments. Moreover, by intervening in treatment decisions, we show that our framework effectively mitigates treatment discrimination from historical data to ensure fair risk score estimation and (non-binary) decision-making processes that benefit all stakeholders.

算法公平因果推断信贷决策

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。