挑战大模型在动作、变化与规划上的开放生成推理能力。
ACPBench Hard: Unrestrained Reasoning about Action, Change, and Planning
- 构建开放式问答的生成型推理数据集,模拟真实规划场景。
- 最大模型平均准确率低于65%,普遍难以应对复杂推理任务。
- 适合评估语言模型在自主决策与长期规划中的实际能力。
ACPBench Hard 是 ACPBench 的生成版本,旨在测试模型在无选项约束下对动作、变化与规划的开放生成推理能力。该数据集包含非选择题形式的原子推理任务,要求模型自主生成答案,更贴近真实规划需求。我们设计了针对每类任务的验证算法以判断答案正确性,并测试多种模型表现。结果显示,即使是最先进的大模型,在多数任务上表现仍不理想,平均准确率不足65%,且没有模型在所有任务中全面领先。这表明当前主流语言模型在复杂规划推理方面仍有巨大提升空间,即便是专门优化的“推理模型”也面临挑战。ACPBench Hard 数据集已开源:https://ibm.github.io/ACPBench。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
The ACPBench dataset provides atomic reasoning tasks required for efficient planning. The dataset is aimed at distilling the complex plan generation task into separate atomic reasoning tasks in their easiest possible form, boolean or multiple-choice questions, where the model has to choose the right answer from the provided options. While the aim of ACPBench is to test the simplest form of reasoning about action and change, when tasked with planning, a model does not typically have options to choose from and thus the reasoning required for planning dictates an open-ended, generative form for these tasks. To that end, we introduce ACPBench Hard, a generative version of ACPBench, with open-ended questions which the model needs to answer. Models that perform well on these tasks could in principle be integrated into a planner or be used directly as a policy. We discuss the complexity of these tasks as well as the complexity of validating the correctness of their answers and present validation algorithms for each task. Equipped with these validators, we test the performance of a variety of models on our tasks and find that for most of these tasks the performance of even the largest models is still subpar. Our experiments show that no model outperforms another in these tasks and with a few exceptions all tested language models score below 65%, indicating that even the current frontier language models have a long way to go before they can reliably reason about planning. In fact, even the so-called reasoning models struggle with solving these reasoning tasks. ACPBench Hard collection is available at the following link: https://ibm.github.io/ACPBench
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。