arXiv:2504.06227cs.CL2025-04被引 17

提出评估大模型解释可信度的新框架,兼顾合理性和忠实性。

LExT: Towards Evaluating Trustworthiness of Natural Language Explanations

  • 设计可泛化的可信度评分框架,平衡解释的合理与忠实
  • 在医疗数据上测试6个模型,发现通用模型忠实性不一致但表现更优
  • 为医疗等敏感领域提供可复现的解释评估工具,适合关注模型透明性的研究者

随着大语言模型在高风险领域日益普及,生成自然语言解释的方法不断涌现。这些解释对提升模型可解释性至关重要,尤其在医疗等需要透明与可靠性的领域。然而,由于大模型生成解释存在潜在问题,亟需可靠的评估框架。现有自然语言生成指标如BLEU和ROUGE仅衡量语法与语义准确性,忽略事实正确性、一致性与忠实性等关键维度。为此,本文提出一个通用框架,用于量化自然语言解释的可信度,综合考量合理性和忠实性,构建语言解释可信度评分(LExT)。该框架在医疗领域使用公开医学数据集,评估了6个模型,包括领域专用和通用模型。结果表明各模型在生成可信解释方面差异显著。观察发现,通用模型虽存在忠实性不一致问题,但整体表现优于领域微调模型。本工作强调在敏感领域使用定制化评估框架的重要性,为提升语言模型在医疗等领域的可信度与透明性奠定基础。代码与实验设置已开源。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

As Large Language Models (LLMs) become increasingly integrated into high-stakes domains, there have been several approaches proposed toward generating natural language explanations. These explanations are crucial for enhancing the interpretability of a model, especially in sensitive domains like healthcare, where transparency and reliability are key. In light of such explanations being generated by LLMs and its known concerns, there is a growing need for robust evaluation frameworks to assess model-generated explanations. Natural Language Generation metrics like BLEU and ROUGE capture syntactic and semantic accuracies but overlook other crucial aspects such as factual accuracy, consistency, and faithfulness. To address this gap, we propose a general framework for quantifying trustworthiness of natural language explanations, balancing Plausibility and Faithfulness, to derive a comprehensive Language Explanation Trustworthiness Score (LExT) (The code and set up to reproduce our experiments are publicly available at https://github.com/cerai-iitm/LExT). Applying our domain-agnostic framework to the healthcare domain using public medical datasets, we evaluate six models, including domain-specific and general-purpose models. Our findings demonstrate significant differences in their ability to generate trustworthy explanations. On comparing these explanations, we make interesting observations such as inconsistencies in Faithfulness demonstrated by general-purpose models and their tendency to outperform domain-specific fine-tuned models. This work further highlights the importance of using a tailored evaluation framework to assess natural language explanations in sensitive fields, providing a foundation for improving the trustworthiness and transparency of language models in healthcare and beyond.

可信度评估大模型解释医疗AI

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。