解释能修复机器人故障印象,尤其在用户期待低时效果显著
Expectations, Explanations, and Embodiment: Attempts at Robot Failure Recovery
- 用视频引导用户形成高低期待,再观察故障时解释的作用
- 低期待下解释显著提升用户满意度与对机器人的表达力感知
- 机器人的外形和交互风格决定解释是否有效,适合设计者参考
期望深刻影响人们对机器人的评价,决定其将故障视为小问题还是致命缺陷。本研究通过两个在线实验(共600名参与者),考察高、低期望(通过简短视频诱导)如何影响用户对机器人故障的感知,以及解释在人机交互中的作用。实验使用两种不同外形的机器人:Furhat 和 Pepper。第一项验证性研究确认视频可有效建立高低期望。第二项研究中,参与者被赋予不同期望后,观看机器人任务失败场景,一半看到故障解释,另一半无解释。结果显示,解释显著改善了用户对Furhat的评价,尤其在低期望条件下;解释提升了满意度与机器人表达力感知,表明清晰说明错误原因有助于重建信任。但对Pepper而言,解释影响微弱,表明机器人形态与互动风格决定了解释的有效性。研究强调,在设计解释策略时需考虑用户初始期望。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Expectations critically shape how people form judgments about robots, influencing whether they view failures as minor technical glitches or deal-breaking flaws. This work explores how high and low expectations, induced through brief video priming, affect user perceptions of robot failures and the utility of explanations in HRI. We conducted two online studies ($N=600$ total participants); each replicated two robots with different embodiments, Furhat and Pepper. In our first study, grounded in expectation theory, participants were divided into two groups, one primed with positive and the other with negative expectations regarding the robot's performance, establishing distinct expectation frameworks. This validation study aimed to verify whether the videos could reliably establish low and high-expectation profiles. In the second study, participants were primed using the validated videos and then viewed a new scenario in which the robot failed at a task. Half viewed a version where the robot explained its failure, while the other half received no explanation. We found that explanations significantly improved user perceptions of Furhat, especially when participants were primed to have lower expectations. Explanations boosted satisfaction and enhanced the robot's perceived expressiveness, indicating that effectively communicating the cause of errors can help repair user trust. By contrast, Pepper's explanations produced minimal impact on user attitudes, suggesting that a robot's embodiment and style of interaction could determine whether explanations can successfully offset negative impressions. Together, these findings underscore the need to consider users' expectations when tailoring explanation strategies in HRI. When expectations are initially low, a cogent explanation can make the difference between dismissing a failure and appreciating the robot's transparency and effort to communicate.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。