用脑电预测脑磁共振信号,发现任务态更准,同次采集数据预测效果更好
EEG-to-fMRI synthesis of task-evoked and spontaneous brain activity: addressing issues of statistical significance and generalizability
- 用时变多通道脑电功率建模,结合稀疏分组LASSO提升预测能力
- 模型在多数被试和条件下显著优于零模型,任务态预测效果优于自发活动
- 跨会话训练导致预测性能下降,提示需避免数据泄露问题
近年来,利用脑电(EEG)特征预测功能磁共振(fMRI)脑活动的合成模型受到广泛关注。尽管已有部分成功案例,但其统计显著性与泛化能力仍待充分验证。本研究基于健康受试者在两个不同会话中采集的数据,评估了脑电对躯体运动网络在任务诱发和自发状态下fMRI活动的预测能力。我们采用稀疏分组LASSO正则化的分布式滞后线性模型,对时变、多通道脑电频谱功率进行建模。结果显示,所学模型优于传统脑电运动节律预测器及大规模单变量相关模型。在大多数被试和条件下,模型预测性能显著优于相应零模型,但自发活动的显著性较低。关键发现是:当训练与测试数据来自同一会话时,预测性能显著提升,表明跨会话训练易引发数据泄漏和乐观偏差。因此,虽然脑电模型可实现具有统计显著性的fMRI预测,但对自发脑活动的预测能力受限,且跨会话泛化效果差。本研究强调需在日益增长的脑电-磁共振合成研究中重视此类问题。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
A growing interest has developed in the problem of training models of EEG features to predict brain activity measured using fMRI, i.e. the problem of EEG-to-fMRI synthesis. Despite some reported success, the statistical significance and generalizability of EEG-to-fMRI predictions remains to be fully demonstrated. Here, we investigate the predictive power of EEG for both task-evoked and spontaneous activity of the somatomotor network measured by fMRI, based on data collected from healthy subjects in two different sessions. We trained subject-specific distributed-lag linear models of time-varying, multi-channel EEG spectral power using Sparse Group LASSO regularization, and we showed that learned models outperformed conventional EEG somatomotor rhythm predictors as well as massive univariate correlation models. Furthermore, we showed that learned models were statistically significantly better than appropriate null models in most subjects and conditions, although less frequently for spontaneous compared to task-evoked activity. Critically, predictions improved significantly when training and testing on data acquired in the same session relative to across sessions, highlighting the importance of temporally separating the collection of train and test data to avoid data leakage and optimistic bias in model generalization. In sum, while we demonstrate that EEG models can provide fMRI predictions with statistical significance, we also show that predictive power is impaired for spontaneous fluctuations in brain activity and for models trained on data acquired in a different session. Our findings highlight the need to explicitly consider these often overlooked issues in the growing literature of EEG-to-fMRI synthesis.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。