arXiv:2505.01085cs.CYcs.AI2025-05被引 5

用代理理论解析AI如何让公众感觉失去控制

Artificial Intelligence in Government: Why People Feel They Lose Control

  • 把政府用AI比作委托代理,分析决策可理解性、可逆性和可挑战性
  • 效率提升初期增强信任,但削弱公众控制感,长期导致信任暴跌
  • 适合关注政务AI治理、民主问责与公众信任的研究者和政策制定者

人工智能在公共管理中的应用快速扩展,从自动化常规任务发展到部署生成式与自主性系统。尽管带来效率与响应性提升,但其融入政府职能引发对公平性、透明度和问责性的担忧。本文运用委托代理理论(PAT),将AI采纳视为一种特殊委托关系,揭示三个核心张力:可评估性(决策是否可理解)、依赖性(委托能否逆转)和可争议性(决策是否可挑战)。这些结构性挑战可能导致“成功中的失败”动态,即早期功能性收益掩盖了对民主合法性的长期风险。为验证该框架,我们在税收、福利和执法领域开展预注册因子调查实验。结果表明,虽然效率提升初期增强了信任,却同时降低了公民的控制感知;当结构性风险显现时,制度信任与控制感均急剧下降,说明AI采纳的隐性成本显著影响公众态度。研究证明,委托代理理论为理解政务AI的制度与政治影响提供了有力视角,强调政策制定者必须透明应对委托风险,以维持公众信任。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

The use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in public administration is expanding rapidly, moving from automating routine tasks to deploying generative and agentic systems that autonomously act on goals. While AI promises greater efficiency and responsiveness, its integration into government functions raises concerns about fairness, transparency, and accountability. This article applies principal-agent theory (PAT) to conceptualize AI adoption as a special case of delegation, highlighting three core tensions: assessability (can decisions be understood?), dependency (can the delegation be reversed?), and contestability (can decisions be challenged?). These structural challenges may lead to a "failure-by-success" dynamic, where early functional gains obscure long-term risks to democratic legitimacy. To test this framework, we conducted a pre-registered factorial survey experiment across tax, welfare, and law enforcement domains. Our findings show that although efficiency gains initially bolster trust, they simultaneously reduce citizens' perceived control. When the structural risks come to the foreground, institutional trust and perceived control both drop sharply, suggesting that hidden costs of AI adoption significantly shape public attitudes. The study demonstrates that PAT offers a powerful lens for understanding the institutional and political implications of AI in government, emphasizing the need for policymakers to address delegation risks transparently to maintain public trust.

AI治理公共信任委托代理

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。