arXiv:2505.02198cs.CYcs.AI2025-05被引 41

大学生用AI工具学习,既享便利也忧诚信与独立思考

Student Perspectives on the Benefits and Risks of AI in Education

  • 通过问卷分析262名本科生对AI助教的看法
  • 最看重即时反馈与学习支持,担忧造假与思维退化
  • 适合教育政策制定者与教师参考,推动AI素养教育

近年来,配备人工智能的聊天机器人在教育场景中应用增多,展现出辅助教学与学习的潜力。然而,其使用也引发了对学术诚信、学生独立解决问题能力及潜在偏见的担忧。为深入了解学生视角,一项针对美国一所大型公立大学的调查收集了262名本科生关于AI聊天机器人在教育中利弊的看法。主题分析识别出若干主要益处:反馈支持、学习协助、教学功能与信息获取。主要风险包括学术诚信问题、信息准确性不足、批判性思维弱化、过度依赖、数据隐私、系统偏见、环境影响以及教育中人性化元素的丧失。学生尤其关注难以区分真人与AI生成内容,甚至真实作业被误判为AI产物。为应对这些关切,机构应制定清晰的AI使用政策,并开设AI素养课程。此举可有效发挥AI在即时反馈与个性化学习支持方面的优势,提升教育质量,同时保障学习过程的完整性。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

The use of chatbots equipped with artificial intelligence (AI) in educational settings has increased in recent years, showing potential to support teaching and learning. However, the adoption of these technologies has raised concerns about their impact on academic integrity, students' ability to problem-solve independently, and potential underlying biases. To better understand students' perspectives and experiences with these tools, a survey was conducted at a large public university in the United States. Through thematic analysis, 262 undergraduate students' responses regarding their perceived benefits and risks of AI chatbots in education were identified and categorized into themes. The results discuss several benefits identified by the students, with feedback and study support, instruction capabilities, and access to information being the most cited. Their primary concerns included risks to academic integrity, accuracy of information, loss of critical thinking skills, the potential development of overreliance, and ethical considerations such as data privacy, system bias, environmental impact, and preservation of human elements in education. While student perceptions align with previously discussed benefits and risks of AI in education, they show heightened concerns about distinguishing between human and AI generated work - particularly in cases where authentic work is flagged as AI-generated. To address students' concerns, institutions can establish clear policies regarding AI use and develop curriculum around AI literacy. With these in place, practitioners can effectively develop and implement educational systems that leverage AI's potential in areas such as immediate feedback and personalized learning support. This approach can enhance the quality of students' educational experiences while preserving the integrity of the learning process with AI.

AI教育学生调研学术诚信AI素养

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。