提出人机共智新框架,揭示协作中认知如何共同演化。
Cognitio Emergens: Agency, Dimensions, and Dynamics in Human-AI Knowledge Co-Creation
- 构建三元框架:权力配置、认知维度、合作动态
- 识别六种认知能力,形成独特能力画像
- 适合科研管理者与政策制定者反思人机协作机制
人机科学协作已从工具使用关系演变为共生演化伙伴关系。当AlphaFold提升蛋白质结构预测时,研究人员面对的是一种能改变其结构-功能问题认知方式的认知伙伴。现有框架将AI视为工具或风险,忽视了知识通过反复互动产生的过程。我们提出Cognitio Emergens(CE)框架,捕捉人机认知伙伴关系的共生特性。基于自组织理论、社会系统理论和组织模块化,框架包含三个部分:权力配置模式(定向、贡献、合作),其中合作关系动态振荡而非线性推进;认知维度刻画发现、整合、投影轴上的六种能力,形成独特的‘能力签名’以指导战略发展;合作动态识别演化力,如认知疏离——研究者虽形式上认可知识,却失去解释控制权。该框架使研究者可诊断维度失衡,机构领导者能设计支持多元权力配置的治理结构,政策制定者可建立超越简单性能指标的评估体系。通过将人机协作重新定义为根本性的共生演化,CE提供了培育既能保持认知完整性又能实现独立人类或AI无法达成突破的伙伴关系的概念工具。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Human-AI scientific collaboration has evolved from tool-user relationships into co-evolutionary partnerships. When AlphaFold improved protein structure prediction, researchers engaged with an epistemic partner that transformed their approach to structure-function problems. Yet existing frameworks position AI as either sophisticated tool or potential risk, overlooking how scientific understanding emerges through recursive interaction. We introduce Cognitio Emergens (CE), a framework that captures the co-evolutionary nature of human-AI epistemic partnerships. Drawing from autopoiesis theory, social systems theory, and organizational modularity, CE integrates three components: Agency Configurations modeling how authority distributes through Directed, Contributory, and Partnership modes, with partnerships oscillating dynamically rather than following linear progression; Epistemic Dimensions capturing six capabilities along Discovery, Integration, and Projection axes, creating distinctive "capability signatures" that guide strategic development; and Partnership Dynamics identifying evolutionary forces including epistemic alienation, where researchers lose interpretive control over knowledge they formally endorse. The framework equips researchers to diagnose dimensional imbalances, institutional leaders to design governance structures supporting multiple agency configurations, and policymakers to develop evaluations beyond simple performance metrics. By reconceptualizing human-AI collaboration as fundamentally co-evolutionary, CE provides conceptual tools for cultivating partnerships that preserve epistemic integrity while enabling transformative breakthroughs neither humans nor AI could achieve independently.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。