用脑筋急转弯测试大模型的创造性解题能力
Creativity or Brute Force? Using Brainteasers as a Window into the Problem-Solving Abilities of Large Language Models
- 用叙事型脑筋急转弯评测模型的多种推理路径
- 部分模型能给出创意解法,但仍有依赖机械计算
- 适合关注AI推理机制与创新能力的研究者
准确率是评估AI系统的核心指标,但难以揭示模型的解题思路。本文提出一种基于长篇叙事式脑筋急转弯的基准测试,以深入探究大语言模型(LLMs)的推理策略。脑筋急转弯具有多种解法:既可通过巧妙洞察快速求解,也可通过冗长的暴力推导完成。研究聚焦于多层推理过程,包括:(1) 将脑筋急转弯语义解析为类似数学竞赛的精确形式;(2) 从该形式生成解答;(3) 基于标准答案自我修正;(4) 生成分步解题草图;(5) 利用提示信息。结果表明,模型在许多情况下可发现富有洞察力的创造性解法,说明其具备解决新问题的某些创造能力。然而,在存在更高效解法时,仍常依赖机械推演,暴露出推理能力改进空间。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Accuracy remains a standard metric for evaluating AI systems, but it offers limited insight into how models arrive at their solutions. In this work, we introduce a benchmark based on brainteasers written in long narrative form to probe more deeply into the types of reasoning strategies that models use. Brainteasers are well-suited for this goal because they can be solved with multiple approaches, such as a few-step solution that uses a creative insight or a longer solution that uses more brute force. We investigate large language models (LLMs) across multiple layers of reasoning, focusing not only on correctness but also on the quality and creativity of their solutions. We investigate many aspects of the reasoning process: (1) semantic parsing of the brainteasers into precise mathematical competition style formats; (2) generating solutions from these mathematical forms; (3) self-correcting solutions based on gold solutions; (4) producing step-by-step sketches of solutions; and (5) making use of hints. We find that LLMs are in many cases able to find creative, insightful solutions to brainteasers, suggesting that they capture some of the capacities needed to solve novel problems in creative ways. Nonetheless, there also remain situations where they rely on brute force despite the availability of more efficient, creative solutions, highlighting a potential direction for improvement in the reasoning abilities of LLMs.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。