arXiv:2505.11095cs.CL2025-05ACL被引 13

首个专利权利要求评估基准,提升AI生成专利的可靠性

Towards Better Evaluation for Generated Patent Claims

  • 构建专家标注的多维度专利权利要求评估体系
  • 新方法与人工评估相关性达最高,超越现有指标
  • 适合专利自动化、AI评估研究者参考

专利权利要求界定保护范围并确立发明的法律边界。撰写这些权利要求是复杂且耗时的过程,通常需资深专利律师参与,对众多中小企业构成较大准入门槛。为应对这一挑战,研究者探索使用大语言模型(LLMs)自动化生成专利权利要求。然而,现有研究指出自动评估指标与人工专家判断存在不一致。为此,我们提出 Patent-CE,首个全面的专利权利要求评估基准,包含由专利专家标注的对比性权利要求评价,聚焦五个关键标准:特征完整性、概念清晰度、术语一致性、逻辑关联性和整体质量。此外,我们提出 PatClaimEval,一种专为专利权利要求设计的新型多维评估方法。实验表明,PatClaimEval 在所有评估标准上与人工专家评价的相关性均优于其他测试指标。本研究为更准确评估自动化专利权利要求生成系统奠定了基础。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Patent claims define the scope of protection and establish the legal boundaries of an invention. Drafting these claims is a complex and time-consuming process that usually requires the expertise of skilled patent attorneys, which can form a large access barrier for many small enterprises. To solve these challenges, researchers have investigated the use of large language models (LLMs) for automating patent claim generation. However, existing studies highlight inconsistencies between automated evaluation metrics and human expert assessments. To bridge this gap, we introduce Patent-CE, the first comprehensive benchmark for evaluating patent claims. Patent-CE includes comparative claim evaluations annotated by patent experts, focusing on five key criteria: feature completeness, conceptual clarity, terminology consistency, logical linkage, and overall quality. Additionally, we propose PatClaimEval, a novel multi-dimensional evaluation method specifically designed for patent claims. Our experiments demonstrate that PatClaimEval achieves the highest correlation with human expert evaluations across all assessment criteria among all tested metrics. This research provides the groundwork for more accurate evaluations of automated patent claim generation systems.

专利生成评估基准LLM应用

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。