arXiv:2505.14349cs.CYcs.AI2025-05被引 3

用公平投票法提升民主,让少数声音被听见。

Upgrading Democracies with Fairer Voting Methods

  • 采用累积投票与等额分配法实现偏好比例代表
  • 相同预算下选出更多项目,覆盖更广地域与偏好
  • 市民更倾向公平投票,体现利他与妥协价值观

投票方法是民主制度的关键设计元素。公民通过它们表达并聚合偏好以达成集体决策。然而,投票结果对规则的敏感性可能超过对选民选择的依赖。尽管重要且已有跨学科进展,多个民主国家仍沿用过时的投票方式,难以适应现代多元社会,缺乏社会创新。本文展示如何通过累积投票、等额分配等替代性优先投票方法升级现实中的民主制度。在瑞士阿劳市的新参与式预算实践中,我们严格评估了这些公平投票方法的显著效果,包含历史与后续数据。结果表明,在相同预算下,更多项目得以入选,且被选项目更广泛地反映了地理分布与偏好多样性,尤其惠及长期被边缘化的选民。我们提供了因果证据,显示市民更偏好比例制投票,其具有强合法性,无需复杂技术解释。同时揭示支持公平投票的市民展现出强烈的利他主义与妥协精神。这些发现为全球民主制度升级提供了新的、亟需的参与蓝图。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Voting methods are instrumental design elements of democracies. Citizens use them to express and aggregate their preferences to reach a collective decision. However, voting outcomes can be as sensitive to voting rules as they are to people's voting choices. Despite significance and interdisciplinary scientific progress, several democracies keep relying on outdated voting methods that do not fit modern, pluralistic societies well, while lacking social innovation. Here, we demonstrate how one can upgrade real-world democracies, namely by using alternative preferential voting methods such as cumulative voting and the method of equal shares designed for a proportional representation of voters' preferences. We rigorously evaluate the striking voting outcomes of these fair voting methods in a new participatory budgeting approach applied in the city of Aarau, Switzerland, including past and follow-up evidence. Results show more winning projects with the same budget. They also show broader geographic and preference representation of citizens by the elected projects, in particular for voters who used to be under-represented. We provide causal evidence showing that citizens prefer proportional voting methods, which possess strong legitimacy without the need of very specialized technical explanations. We also reveal strong underlying democratic values exhibited by citizens who support fair voting methods such as altruism and compromise. These findings come with the momentum to unleash a new and long-awaited participation blueprint of how to upgrade democracies globally.

民主改革公平投票参与式预算

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。