首次评估TabPFN v2在开放环境下的表现,发现其泛化能力有限。
Realistic Evaluation of TabPFN v2 in Open Environments
- 构建统一框架评估模型在真实开放场景下的表现
- 在开放环境中性能显著下降,仅适用于小规模、协变量偏移任务
- 建议建立开放环境基准与多指标评估体系
表格数据因广泛存在于现实场景中,成为机器学习研究热点。尽管树模型长期主导表格任务,新提出的深度学习模型TabPFN v2展现出卓越性能与可扩展性潜力。然而,现有研究多局限于封闭环境,忽视了开放环境中的常见挑战。本文首次全面评估TabPFN v2在开放环境下的适应性,构建涵盖多种真实挑战的统一评估框架,并基于此检验其鲁棒性。实验结果表明,TabPFN v2在开放环境中表现受限,仅适用于小规模、协变量偏移且类别平衡的任务;而树模型仍是开放环境下通用表格任务的更优选择。为促进未来研究,我们呼吁建立开放环境表格基准、采用多指标评估及通用模块以增强模型鲁棒性。评估框架已开源:https://anonymous.4open.science/r/tabpfn-ood-4E65。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Tabular data, owing to its ubiquitous presence in real-world domains, has garnered significant attention in machine learning research. While tree-based models have long dominated tabular machine learning tasks, the recently proposed deep learning model TabPFN v2 has emerged, demonstrating unparalleled performance and scalability potential. Although extensive research has been conducted on TabPFN v2 to further improve performance, the majority of this research remains confined to closed environments, neglecting the challenges that frequently arise in open environments. This raises the question: Can TabPFN v2 maintain good performance in open environments? To this end, we conduct the first comprehensive evaluation of TabPFN v2's adaptability in open environments. We construct a unified evaluation framework covering various real-world challenges and assess the robustness of TabPFN v2 under open environments scenarios using this framework. Empirical results demonstrate that TabPFN v2 shows significant limitations in open environments but is suitable for small-scale, covariate-shifted, and class-balanced tasks. Tree-based models remain the optimal choice for general tabular tasks in open environments. To facilitate future research on open environments challenges, we advocate for open environments tabular benchmarks, multi-metric evaluation, and universal modules to strengthen model robustness. We publicly release our evaluation framework at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/tabpfn-ood-4E65.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。