arXiv:2505.16513cs.CV2025-05中稿 · the 2024 REMADE Ci…被引 4

实测发现光学识别难分真实垃圾场塑料,因依赖颜色形状易出错。

Detailed Evaluation of Modern Machine Learning Approaches for Optic Plastics Sorting

  • 用2万+图像构建新数据集,测试主流视觉模型在真实场景表现
  • 模型对颜色、形状依赖强,实际分拣准确率低,误判率高
  • 适合关注垃圾分类自动化瓶颈的研究者或从业者参考

根据美国环保署数据,仅25%废弃物被回收,60%的美国城市提供路边回收服务。塑料回收率仅为8%,另有16%被焚烧,76%进入填埋场。低回收率源于污染、经济激励不足和技术难题。自动化分拣是提升回收的关键,企业如AMP Robotics和Greyparrot采用光学系统,物料回收设施(MRFs)使用近红外(NIR)传感器识别塑料类型。现代光学分拣依赖计算机视觉技术,如基于ResNet等深度骨干网络的两阶段检测器Mask R-CNN,以及单阶段检测器YOLO。尽管这些方法在理想条件下表现优异,但真实场景中仍面临挑战。本研究收集了超过20,000张来自不同来源的图像,构建新数据集,结合公开与自研机器学习流程,评估光学识别在实际分拣中的能力与局限。通过Grad-CAM、显著性图和混淆矩阵分析模型行为。结果表明,现有光学识别方法在真实MRF环境中对塑料分类成功率有限,主要因其依赖颜色、形状等物理属性,难以应对复杂多变的真实环境。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

According to the EPA, only 25% of waste is recycled, and just 60% of U.S. municipalities offer curbside recycling. Plastics fare worse, with a recycling rate of only 8%; an additional 16% is incinerated, while the remaining 76% ends up in landfills. The low plastic recycling rate stems from contamination, poor economic incentives, and technical difficulties, making efficient recycling a challenge. To improve recovery, automated sorting plays a critical role. Companies like AMP Robotics and Greyparrot utilize optical systems for sorting, while Materials Recovery Facilities (MRFs) employ Near-Infrared (NIR) sensors to detect plastic types. Modern optical sorting uses advances in computer vision such as object recognition and instance segmentation, powered by machine learning. Two-stage detectors like Mask R-CNN use region proposals and classification with deep backbones like ResNet. Single-stage detectors like YOLO handle detection in one pass, trading some accuracy for speed. While such methods excel under ideal conditions with a large volume of labeled training data, challenges arise in realistic scenarios, emphasizing the need to further examine the efficacy of optic detection for automated sorting. In this study, we compiled novel datasets totaling 20,000+ images from varied sources. Using both public and custom machine learning pipelines, we assessed the capabilities and limitations of optical recognition for sorting. Grad-CAM, saliency maps, and confusion matrices were employed to interpret model behavior. We perform this analysis on our custom trained models from the compiled datasets. To conclude, our findings are that optic recognition methods have limited success in accurate sorting of real-world plastics at MRFs, primarily because they rely on physical properties such as color and shape.

塑料回收视觉识别工业应用

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。