arXiv:2505.18553cs.HCcs.RO2025-05被引 3

教工厂如何选AI工具:用知识图谱还是大模型?

Applying Ontologies and Knowledge Augmented Large Language Models to Industrial Automation: A Decision-Making Guidance for Achieving Human-Robot Collaboration in Industry 5.0

  • 对比大模型、本体、知识图谱在制造场景的适用性
  • 发现多领域协作时大模型更优,资源少时本体仍可靠
  • 适合制造业决策者和工业AI落地工程师

大型语言模型(LLMs)在制造业中的应用日益受到关注,尤其在工业5.0背景下。然而,在何种情境下使用LLMs、其他自然语言处理技术、本体或知识图谱仍未明确。本文针对不同工业场景,基于产品从设计到制造所需跨领域数量,提供选择建议,强调人机协作与制造韧性。研究分析了各类技术的起源与优势,发现复杂多域任务中大模型表现更佳,而低依赖或资源受限场景仍需依赖本体与知识图谱。同时讨论了部署中的计算成本与可解释性挑战,为制造商提供语言驱动AI工具的落地路线图。文中还提出一种大型知识语言模型架构,支持根据任务复杂度与算力灵活配置,提升透明性与适应性。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

The rapid advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) has resulted in interest in their potential applications within manufacturing systems, particularly in the context of Industry 5.0. However, determining when to implement LLMs versus other Natural Language Processing (NLP) techniques, ontologies or knowledge graphs, remains an open question. This paper offers decision-making guidance for selecting the most suitable technique in various industrial contexts, emphasizing human-robot collaboration and resilience in manufacturing. We examine the origins and unique strengths of LLMs, ontologies, and knowledge graphs, assessing their effectiveness across different industrial scenarios based on the number of domains or disciplines required to bring a product from design to manufacture. Through this comparative framework, we explore specific use cases where LLMs could enhance robotics for human-robot collaboration, while underscoring the continued relevance of ontologies and knowledge graphs in low-dependency or resource-constrained sectors. Additionally, we address the practical challenges of deploying these technologies, such as computational cost and interpretability, providing a roadmap for manufacturers to navigate the evolving landscape of Language based AI tools in Industry 5.0. Our findings offer a foundation for informed decision-making, helping industry professionals optimize the use of Language Based models for sustainable, resilient, and human-centric manufacturing. We also propose a Large Knowledge Language Model architecture that offers the potential for transparency and configuration based on complexity of task and computing resources available.

工业5.0大模型知识图谱人机协作

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。