重新审视视频异常检测的评估标准,解决评测偏差与过拟合问题。
Rethinking Metrics and Benchmarks of Video Anomaly Detection
- 引入多轮标注的概率AUC/AP,缓解单次标注偏差。
- 设计延迟感知精度指标,鼓励早期准确发现异常。
- 构建两个硬级正常场景基准,评估模型场景过拟合能力。
视频异常检测(VAD)旨在识别与预期不符的异常行为,近年来受到广泛关注。现有研究主要聚焦于模型架构与训练策略,而对评估指标和基准的重视不足。本文通过全面分析,揭示当前实践中的三大局限:1)现有指标受单次标注偏差显著影响;2)现有指标未能奖励异常的早期检测;3)现有基准无法评估全监督/弱监督算法的场景过拟合。为此,我们提出三种新评估方法:首先,基于多轮标注构建概率AUC/AP(Prob-AUC/AP)指标,以减轻单次标注偏差;其次,设计延迟感知平均精度(LaAP)指标,奖励早期且准确的异常检测;最后,引入两个专为评估场景过拟合而设计的硬级正常基准(UCF-HN、MSAD-HN)。我们使用这些新方法对十种主流VAD方法进行了性能对比,为未来VAD模型发展提供新视角。代码与数据已公开于https://github.com/Kamino666/RethinkingVAD。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Video Anomaly Detection (VAD), which aims to detect anomalies that deviate from expectation, has attracted increasing attention in recent years. Existing advancements in VAD primarily focus on model architectures and training strategies, while devoting insufficient attention to evaluation metrics and benchmarks. In this paper, we rethink VAD evaluation methods through comprehensive analyses, revealing three critical limitations in current practices: 1) existing metrics are significantly influenced by single annotation bias; 2) current metrics fail to reward early detection of anomalies; 3) available benchmarks lack the capability to evaluate scene overfitting of fully/weakly-supervised algorithms. To address these limitations, we propose three novel evaluation methods: first, we establish probabilistic AUC/AP (Prob-AUC/AP) metrics utlizing multi-round annotations to mitigate single annotation bias; second, we develop a Latency-aware Average Precision (LaAP) metric that rewards early and accurate anomaly detection; and finally, we introduce two hard normal benchmarks (UCF-HN, MSAD-HN) with videos specifically designed to evaluate scene overfitting. We report performance comparisons of ten state-of-the-art VAD approaches using our proposed evaluation methods, providing novel perspectives for future VAD model development. We release our data and code in https://github.com/Kamino666/RethinkingVAD.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。