arXiv:2505.20761cs.LGstat.ML2025-05被引 5

提出无需样本即可估计最优分类误差的新方法,适用于带噪声软标签场景。

Practical estimation of the optimal classification error with soft labels and calibration

  • 基于软标签设计无样本偏差估计器,适应类别分离程度自适应收敛。
  • 证明即使完美校准的软标签仍可能导致误差估计不准,需更强假设。
  • 采用保序校准实现统计一致估计,适合隐私敏感的实际应用。

尽管近年来机器学习系统性能显著提升,但对模型可优化极限的探讨仍不足。本文针对二分类场景,提出一种实用且理论支持的方法来估计贝叶斯误差(最优分类错误率)。我们扩展了先前使用软标签估计贝叶斯误差的工作:第一,理论上分析硬标签估计器的偏差性质,发现其衰减速率随类条件分布分离度自适应提升,且在每实例多硬标签时可显著快于原有结果;第二,解决软标签被污染的更复杂情形,揭示仅具备校准保证不足以确保估计准确,即使软标签完全校准也可能导致严重偏差。随后证明,在弱于以往工作的假设下,保序校准可提供统计一致估计。所提方法为实例无关型,无需访问输入样本,适用于因隐私限制无法获取实例的场景。合成与真实数据集实验验证了方法有效性与理论正确性。代码已开源:https://github.com/RyotaUshio/bayes-error-estimation。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

While the performance of machine learning systems has experienced significant improvement in recent years, relatively little attention has been paid to the fundamental question: to what extent can we improve our models? This paper provides a means of answering this question in the setting of binary classification, which is practical and theoretically supported. We extend a previous work that utilizes soft labels for estimating the Bayes error, the optimal error rate, in two important ways. First, we theoretically investigate the properties of the bias of the hard-label-based estimator discussed in the original work. We reveal that the decay rate of the bias is adaptive to how well the two class-conditional distributions are separated, and it can decay significantly faster than the previous result suggested as the number of hard labels per instance grows. Second, we tackle a more challenging problem setting: estimation with corrupted soft labels. One might be tempted to use calibrated soft labels instead of clean ones. However, we reveal that calibration guarantee is not enough, that is, even perfectly calibrated soft labels can result in a substantially inaccurate estimate. Then, we show that isotonic calibration can provide a statistically consistent estimator under an assumption weaker than that of the previous work. Our method is instance-free, i.e., we do not assume access to any input instances. This feature allows it to be adopted in practical scenarios where the instances are not available due to privacy issues. Experiments with synthetic and real-world datasets show the validity of our methods and theory. The code is available at https://github.com/RyotaUshio/bayes-error-estimation.

贝叶斯误差软标签校准估计

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。