arXiv:2506.06540cs.CYcs.AI2025-06被引 1

用大模型模拟专家判断,快速分析重大政策冲击前的公众认知。

Large Language Models Can Be a Viable Substitute for Expert Political Surveys When a Shock Disrupts Traditional Measurement Approaches

  • 通过成对比较提示,用大模型生成联邦机构意识形态评分
  • 模型得分与事前专家评估高度一致,且能预测被裁撤机构
  • 适合研究突发事件后传统调研失效时的因果因素分析

重大事件(如2025年联邦政府效率部裁员)发生后,专家判断受结果影响,难以还原事件前的真实认知。本文论证,基于海量数字媒体训练的大语言模型(LLMs)可在传统测量方法失效时替代专家政治调查。以美国政府效率部(DOGE)裁员为例,我们采用成对比较提示生成联邦执行机构的意识形态评分,结果显示这些评分与事前专家测量高度一致,并能有效预测哪些机构被目标锁定。此外,在控制意识形态后,模型仍可捕捉“知识型机构”感知度与被裁关联性。该案例表明,大模型可快速验证冲击事件背后的假设因素。最后提出两项标准,界定研究人员何时可使用大模型替代专家调查。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

After a disruptive event or shock, such as the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) federal layoffs of 2025, expert judgments are colored by knowledge of the outcome. This can make it difficult or impossible to reconstruct the pre-event perceptions needed to study the factors associated with the event. This position paper argues that large language models (LLMs), trained on vast amounts of digital media data, can be a viable substitute for expert political surveys when a shock disrupts traditional measurement. We analyze the DOGE layoffs as a specific case study for this position. We use pairwise comparison prompts with LLMs and derive ideology scores for federal executive agencies. These scores replicate pre-layoff expert measures and predict which agencies were targeted by DOGE. We also use this same approach and find that the perceptions of certain federal agencies as knowledge institutions predict which agencies were targeted by DOGE, even when controlling for ideology. This case study demonstrates that using LLMs allows us to rapidly and easily test the associated factors hypothesized behind the shock. More broadly, our case study of this recent event exemplifies how LLMs offer insights into the correlational factors of the shock when traditional measurement techniques fail. We conclude by proposing a two-part criterion for when researchers can turn to LLMs as a substitute for expert political surveys.

大模型应用政治分析因果推断

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。