AI开发者忽视神经多样性,可能加剧自闭症群体边缘化。
"I Hadn't Thought About That": Creators of Human-like AI Weigh in on Ethics And Neurodivergence
- 访谈AI设计者,发现其对神经多样性认知不足
- 多数开发者未意识到其设计会强化神经常态行为规范
- 建议推动更包容的AI伦理与系统性改革
类人人工智能代理(如机器人和聊天机器人)日益普及,但引发多重伦理问题。首要问题是如何定义‘人性’,以及这种定义对历史上被科学研究所去人性化化的群体的影响。自闭症人群尤其因被比作机器人而长期遭受去人性化,因此必须防止此类边缘化在促进神经常态社交行为的AI中重现。其次,这些代理的普遍使用也带来模型偏见与可及性问题。本研究通过调研技术创建者与设计者的经历,探讨其对神经多样性理解与接纳程度,以及使工作更适应多样化用户需求所面临的挑战。尽管神经多样性个体常因其独特的沟通方式被边缘化,但几乎所有参与者均忽视了其终端用户及其他AI制作者可能从其作品中得出的关于沟通规范的结论。这凸显了其整体伦理考量的重大缺口,部分参与者还存在神经常态假设,即认为某些行为与特质能区分‘人类’与‘机器人’,并将其复制到自身工作中。我们分析了这种做法对社会中自闭症包容性的潜在影响,并提出迈向更伦理研究方向的系统性改进建议。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Human-like AI agents such as robots and chatbots are becoming increasingly popular, but they present a variety of ethical concerns. The first concern is in how we define humanness, and how our definition impacts communities historically dehumanized by scientific research. Autistic people in particular have been dehumanized by being compared to robots, making it even more important to ensure this marginalization is not reproduced by AI that may promote neuronormative social behaviors. Second, the ubiquitous use of these agents raises concerns surrounding model biases and accessibility. In our work, we investigate the experiences of the people who build and design these technologies to gain insights into their understanding and acceptance of neurodivergence, and the challenges in making their work more accessible to users with diverse needs. Even though neurodivergent individuals are often marginalized for their unique communication styles, nearly all participants overlooked the conclusions their end-users and other AI system makers may draw about communication norms from the implementation and interpretation of humanness applied in participants' work. This highlights a major gap in their broader ethical considerations, compounded by some participants' neuronormative assumptions about the behaviors and traits that distinguish "humans" from "bots" and the replication of these assumptions in their work. We examine the impact this may have on autism inclusion in society and provide recommendations for additional systemic changes towards more ethical research directions.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。